Question

What alternative do you believe Mr. Markham should select? Offer your rationale for your selection. The...

What alternative do you believe Mr. Markham should select? Offer your rationale for your selection.

The Case
This case was developed by the MIT Sloan School of Management. It is part of their “Learning Edge,” a free learning resource. This case was prepared by John Minahan and Cate Reavis. This case is based on actual events. Actual names are changed; some of the narrative is fictional.
In early 2012, as he prepared to enter a meeting with the board of trustees of a state pension fund, Harry Markham, CFA, couldn't help but feel professionally conflicted.
Since earning his Master of Finance in 2004 at one of the top business schools in the United States, Markham had worked for Investment Consulting Associates (ICA), a firm that gave investment advice to pension funds.
Since joining the firm, Markham had grown increasingly concerned over how public sector pension fund liabilities were being valued. If he valued the liabilities using the valuation and financial analysis principles he learned in his Master of Finance and CFA programs, he would get numbers almost twice as high as those reported by the funds.
This would not be such a problem if he were allowed to make adjustments to the official numbers, but neither his clients nor his firm was interested in questioning them. The board did not want to hear that the fund's liabilities were much larger than the number being captured by the Government Accounting Standards Board (GASB) rules and his firm wanted to keep the board of trustees happy.
How, Markham wondered, was he supposed to give sound investment advice to state treasurers and boards of trustees working from financials that he knew were grossly misleading?
Markham's dilemma came down to conflicting loyalties: loyalty to his firm, loyalty to the boards of trustees and others who made investment decisions for public pensions and who, in turn, hired his firm to provide investment expertise, and loyalty to the pensioners themselves, as Markham believed was called for by the CFA Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct.
In his role as investment advisor, the differing views on how to value pension liabilities challenged Markham on both a practical and an ethical level. "My role is not to decide the value of liabilities," he explained.
That is the actuary's job. My role is to give investment advice. However, as an investment advisor, the first thing you want to understand is the client's circumstances. That is a basic ethical precept. The CFA professional standards say you should never give advice without knowing what your client's circumstances are. And so what happens is that we have these funds that are grossly short of money, but the accounting does not show them as being grossly short of money. I make the case within my firm that we need to know where we
are starting before we give advice. And perhaps our advice would be different if the client knew they were starting from a multi-billion-dollar hole that they're seemingly not aware of.
In addition to the fact that Markham was constrained by not having what he believed were accurate accounting figures to work with, he was also well aware that his clients did not like bad news. He feared that if he was to raise the liability issue, he and his firm could very well be fired:
Most plan sponsors want to minimize near-term contributions to their pension fund, and this makes them predisposed to points of view that justify higher discount rates. Furthermore, investment committees and staffs consider their mandate to be to earn, at least, the discount rate assumed by actuaries. The social pressure to embrace overly optimistic return expectations can be enormous. As one plan sponsor told me, ‘It would not be in plan members' interest to lower the discount rate because the increase in liabilities would so shock the taxpayers and the state legislature that it would undermine political support for the plan.' Given this context, plan sponsors do not want to hear the news that they are less well funded than the numbers show and may blame the messenger. Moreover, if it is an elected official you are dealing with; they do not want a crisis on their watch.
Nevertheless, an investment advisor has a professional responsibility to help plan sponsors make sound investment decisions, and understanding one's financial condition is a necessary precursor to making sound investment decisions. This may require telling plan sponsors things they do not want to hear. If investment advisors do not do this, they become enablers of their clients' denial and of the poor decisions that result from that denial.
As a CFA charterholder, Markham annually attested to his compliance with the Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct. Specifically, CFAs must not knowingly make any misrepresentations in investment analysis recommendations. "So if you have an investment recommendation that is based on bad numbers," Markham began, "numbers that are legal and comply with the rules, but you know they are bad, are you violating this ethical rule?"
As Markham was summoned into the conference room to begin his presentation to the board of the state pension fund, he was wrestling with whether or not to raise the liability issue. He knew there were risks either way. There was the risk that his client would choose to take their business elsewhere if he told them what he believed to be the fund's financial reality. Furthermore, such a move would not only result in lost business but would likely be interpreted as disloyalty towards his firm.
Then he thought about what did not happen during the 2008 financial crisis, and this reality gnawed at him:
When the subprime crisis played out, everybody was asking why, even though all these people had a role in making it happen, no one spoke up? Therefore, does somebody who is playing a bit part in creating a reprise of the last crisis have a responsibility to speak up on behalf of the pensioners
themselves even though this is contrary to the wishes of their employer and the board of trustees who has hired their employer to provide investment advice?

0 0
Add a comment Improve this question Transcribed image text
Request Professional Answer

Request Answer!

We need at least 10 more requests to produce the answer.

0 / 10 have requested this problem solution

The more requests, the faster the answer.

Request! (Login Required)


All students who have requested the answer will be notified once they are available.
Know the answer?
Add Answer to:
What alternative do you believe Mr. Markham should select? Offer your rationale for your selection. The...
Your Answer:

Post as a guest

Your Name:

What's your source?

Earn Coins

Coins can be redeemed for fabulous gifts.

Similar Homework Help Questions
  • Marcetta, Wong & Palmirotto Investment Company, a corporation dedicated to brokerage, has as ...

    Marcetta, Wong & Palmirotto Investment Company, a corporation dedicated to brokerage, has as General Manager Sherry Faye Stull, in addition to being the principal officer the which is in charge of the portfolios of rich and famous clients. The General Manager disagrees with the system proposed by Financial Investment Decision Support System Group because it does not think it's right for the needs of the company. In the investment firm there is a variety of portfolio managers, some of the...

  • 1. Do you agree with Deloitte's assertion that Adams had no "substantive role" in the 2008...

    1. Do you agree with Deloitte's assertion that Adams had no "substantive role" in the 2008 and 2009 Caesars audits? Defend your answer. 2. The SEC applies a principles-based approach to mitigating the risks that may undercut auditor independence. Identify the four guiding principles applied by the SEC to protect the independence of auditors of public companies. 3. Assume Adams had used his personal funds to finance his gaming activities in the Caesars casino. Under those circumstances, would he have...

  • You have just completed an interview with the newly formed audit committee of the Andrews Street...

    You have just completed an interview with the newly formed audit committee of the Andrews Street Youth Centre (ASYC). This organization was created to keep neighborhood youth off the streets by providing recreational facilities where they can meet, exercise, play indoor sports, and hold dances. Since its inception, the organization has managed to survive on the basis of user fees charged to parents whose children use the program. This year the center received support from a new provincial government program,...

  • 1. Analyze the major challanges USB faced in the last 5 years, in your opinion, what...

    1. Analyze the major challanges USB faced in the last 5 years, in your opinion, what were the crucial factors in the banks downturn? 2. what are the main triggers to change the banks approach to communication and what is different today regarding the dealings and relationship to its share-and stakeholders? 3. How would you evaluate the constant replacement of the banks chairman and CEO? 4. in view of the future strategy of USB, what are your suggestions in order...

  • 1. Analyze the major challanges USB faced in the last 5 years, in your opinion, what were the cru...

    1. Analyze the major challanges USB faced in the last 5 years, in your opinion, what were the crucial factors in the banks downturn? 2. what are the main triggers to change the banks approach to communication and what is different today regarding the dealings and relationship to its share-and stakeholders? 3. How would you evaluate the constant replacement of the banks chairman and CEO? 4. in view of the future strategy of USB, what are your suggestions in order...

  • Select two of the discussion questions and analyze the case study using project management principles. Apply...

    Select two of the discussion questions and analyze the case study using project management principles. Apply your knowledge of project management to the facts presented in the case study to describe how you would proceed. We only need to answer one of the questions. A thorough answer will probably require 300 to 500 words for each question.   Feel free to use text bullets, tables, or graphics to summarize your points. Questions Q1: Make or Buy decision – Describe the make...

  • 1) Discuss the company's top risks? 2) Discuss whether the company treats risk reactively or proactively?...

    1) Discuss the company's top risks? 2) Discuss whether the company treats risk reactively or proactively? 3) Do you observe a lack of understanding of potential exposures? 4) Does the company focus on internal risks or external risks? 5) Do you think the company is well prepared to respond to potential risks? Orange County he t die Following the debocie Orange County o dmorych of control procedures and financial gove nonce and d e setof o n policies December 1994...

  • In your judgement, and given only the facts described in this case, should the management of...

    In your judgement, and given only the facts described in this case, should the management of Massey energy Company be held morally responsible for the deaths of the 29 miners? Explain in detail. Suppose that nothing more is learned about the explosion other than what is described in this case. Do you think Don Blankership should be held morally responsible for the deaths of the 29 miners? Explain in detail. Given only the facts described in this case, should the...

  • Read the following article: Give arguments to support your views. Do you think that Mark Zuckerberg...

    Read the following article: Give arguments to support your views. Do you think that Mark Zuckerberg or any other CEO has the right to dole out large sums of money for philanthropy? Do you say that is it enough for large corporations just to donate funds or should they also manage them? What are the merits and demerits of management such funds? Five years ago, Facebook Inc. chief executive Mark Zuckerberg went on Oprah Winfrey's television show to pledge $100...

  • Case: Enron: Questionable Accounting Leads to CollapseIntroductionOnce upon a time, there was a gleaming...

    Case: Enron: Questionable Accounting Leads to CollapseIntroductionOnce upon a time, there was a gleaming office tower in Houston, Texas. In front of that gleaming tower was a giant “E,” slowly revolving, flashing in the hot Texas sun. But in 2001, the Enron Corporation, which once ranked among the top Fortune 500 companies, would collapse under a mountain of debt that had been concealed through a complex scheme of off-balance-sheet partnerships. Forced to declare bankruptcy, the energy firm laid off 4,000...

ADVERTISEMENT
Free Homework Help App
Download From Google Play
Scan Your Homework
to Get Instant Free Answers
Need Online Homework Help?
Ask a Question
Get Answers For Free
Most questions answered within 3 hours.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT