The redbrick bank in Weir, Kan., in a building cater-corner from the mortuary on Main Street, does not look much like a candidate for the bank of the future.
Inside, an Emerson boombox with a fully extended silver antenna is tuned to KJMK, Classic Hits. The huge steel vault, from the Mosler Safe Company, was used to lock up former owners of the bank overnight during an armed heist in 1959. And the storage room in the back contains an old, unlabeled bottle of brown moonshine.
Beneath these holdovers, though, the Citizens Bank of Weir—or CBW, as it was renamed—has been taken apart and rebuilt, from its fiber optic cables up, so it can offer services not available at even the nation’s largest banks.
The creation of the new bank, and the maintenance of the old one, are the work of a couple who were born in India and ended up in Kansas after living in Silicon Valley and passing through jobs at Google and Lehman Brothers.
Suresh Ramamurthi, 46, and his wife, Suchitra Padmanabhan, 44, bought CBW largely with their savings in 2009, just after the financial crisis….
Their work is an unusual experiment: a new kind of mom-and-pop business trying to reshape a highly regulated and innovation-resistant industry. The new services that CBW is providing, like instant payments to any bank in the United States, direct remittance transfers abroad and specialized debit cards, might seem as if they should be painless upgrades in an age of high-frequency trading and interplanetary space missions. But with most banks, it still takes longer to send money to another country or even to another state than it does to travel the same distance.
The slowness of current methods of moving money is a widely acknowledged problem in the financial industry. The Federal Reserve has been holding meetings for its initiative, called Faster Payments, which has the goal of devising safe and speedy payment methods.
But hastening the movement of money creates risk for banks, because it generally means less time to catch fraudulent transactions. Having paid fines and penalties for the outsize risks they took before the financial crisis, banks are loath to take on new risks. They have been occupied with “getting their house in order,” rather than introducing products, according to Steve Kenneally, the payment systems specialist at the American Bankers Association….
The most obvious problem to attack was the difficulty of making instant money transfers from one bank account to another. This is already possible in many countries, including Mexico and Britain, but in the United States the primary option that consumers have to transfer money is still the A.C.H. payment. Requests for A.C.H. transfers are collected by banks and submitted in batches, once a day, and the banks receiving the transfers also process the payments once a day, leading to long waits. Wire transfers move faster, with some being settled in hours, but they cost significantly more, and are still not instant.
Last year, big banks helped scuttle a plan that would have expedited the A.C.H. system, in part because it would have jeopardized the fees they earn from wire transfers. Large banks are experimenting with faster transfer systems, like QuickPay from JPMorgan Chase, but these are generally instant only between customers of certain banks….
1. The article describes a trade-off in two risks banks face: liquidity risk and operational risk. By speeding up payments, banks will be able to turn deposits into cash more quickly, thus increasing liquidity, but at the risk for more potential fraud. Is it worth it? Why or why not?
2. The article also points out that it may not be risks the banks are really concerned with. Why do you think a change in risk management has been so slow to come about?
Question 1
To understand this question, let us first understand the two terms. Liquidity risk is the risk that the banks' short term liquid assets (cash, government bonds etc.) may not be sufficient to meet its short term liabilities (call money, interbank loans etc.).
Operational risk is the risk of loss resulting from inadequate or failed internal processes, people and systems or external events.
While banks are required to keep aside some part of their capital for operational risk, liquidity risks are monitored through liquidity ratios or NSFR (Net stable funding ratio).
Over the years specially after the financial crisis, availability of capital at banks have taken a major hit with regulators tightening the screws by raising the capital norms and requirements. Banks have come under increasing margin and profit pressures trying to manage the two levers.
In the given case, instant payments do create operational risks for a bank which may require them to reserve more capital and ultimately impacting their profitability. However, liquidity risks are lower. While it does seem that banks may be hurt by activating instant transfers due to higher operational risk and lower fees on the same, they make lose out in the long run, specially due to the new age and fintech companies crowding the marketplace. So banks are better advised to keep up the changing competitive dynamics and adopting these new age technologies.
Question 2
There are various reasons due to which banks have been slow at changing their risk management practices. Some of the them are:
a. Some of the largest banks have been in existence for decades with legacy systems, people and processes in place. Immediately after the financial crisis, there were remarkable changes in the norms and regulations. Banks were naturally not able to keep pace with the same.
b. Profits and margins of the banks have come under huge pressure due to changing regulatory landscape and emerging new technological players. These have forced them to focus more on cutting costs, leaving less room for making the required IT spends.
The redbrick bank in Weir, Kan., in a building cater-corner from the mortuary on Main Street,...
Wall Street” fulfills an important role for “main street”. It channels funds from savers to borrowers in the most effective way possible. However, its foundations are fragile by construction; for instance, banks borrow short term funds (including deposits) and lend for long terms investment projects. So they may become illiquid if too many deposits are withdrawn on a short notice. They are also exposed to other risks, such interest rate changes and the risk that loans are not repaid (credit...
5. Bank loans Short-term financing through bank loans Consider this case: Central Corp. needs to take out a one-year bank loan of $500,000 and has been offered loan terms by two different banks. One bank has offered a simple interest loan of 9% that requires monthly payments. The loan principal will be paid back at the end of the year. Another bank has offered 6% add-on interest to be repaid in 12 equal monthly installments. Based on a 360-day year,...
Interview with Timothy Geithner February 12, 2015 President, Warburg Pincus; former Secretary of the Treasury of the United States; former President of the Federal Reserve Bank of New York. Has the experience of the crisis changed your view of the central bank policy tool kit? Secretary Geithner: In the United States, we completely redefined the lender of last resort tool kit, and the Federal Reserve Board Chairman redefined the frontiers of how to think about monetary policy at the zero...
QUESTION 1 Does the Basel II Accord deserve its share of the blame in the run up to the financial crisis of 2007 Those who say "no" however point to shortcomings of Basel 1 Accord as the possible reason. At a time when countries had just begun the implementation of the Basel II Accord, the remnants of the Basel I en with its lack of sensitivity and inflexibility to rapid innovations, could have created perverse regulatory incentives to simply move...
41 The money supply is a curve that is typically drawn as a vertical line on the standard money supply - money demand graph that is used in the study of monetary policy. We all know the money supply is only controlled by the Federal Reserve Bank. Conclusion: In the audio visual lecture Professor Torres stated that anytime we see a supply curve drawn as a vertical curve line, then that means that the product or service is 100 percent...
Read the attached article. Do you feel one style of banking
control is more stable than the other? Why? Does one banking method
minimize market volatility and risk better or is it just packaged
differently? Do you feel the US (Western) Banking system can better
control the patterns of behavior going forward that have caused
economic damage in the past? Should the Fed continue its stimulus
policy, reduce it or abandon it entirely (Google some recent
articles to research this)? (Please...
Question 1 (1 point) Saved In a world without deposit insurance we would expect to see all the following EXCEPT: Question 1 options: frequent bank runs. the public being reluctant to deposit in banks. people keeping more money in cookie jars and under the mattress. Question 2 (1 point) Saved All the following are current regulations on banks, EXCEPT: Question 2 options: Banks need to show their books to on-site examiners. Banks need to hold a certain amount of capital...
True/False (1 Point each) 1) When bond prices decrease, their yields to maturity increase. 2) The best forms of money and financial systems enjoy the benefits of trust, belief, and stability. 3) A fundamental function of a commercial bank is to take in deposits and make loans. 4) Traditional banks operate with low margins and high leverage. 5) Rates on bonds issued by a government can be negative. 6) ) The default risk premium is the same as the credit...
18 Congress has the legal right to force the Federal Reserve Bank to accept and carry out their suggested recommendations regarding Monetary Policy. 8 03:57:44 True or False True False 19 The Federal Reserve Bank is the chief regulatory agency among all of the financial regulatory agencies like the SEC, FDIC, etc... The Federal Reserve Bank has the most regulatory power. 03:57:40 Multiple Choice This is foise - the US Treasury Department has the most regulatory power in the U.S....
answer please
25. A bank borrows money from another bank on an overnight basis to meet reserve requirements in the: a. stock market. b. bond market. c. Federal funds market. d. U.S.Treasury bill market. 26. Fiscal policy in the United States is the responsibility of the: a. US Treasury b. Federal Reserve c. Internal Revenue Service d. US Congress and Administration 27. Monetary policy in the United States is the responsibility of the: b. Federal Reserve a. US Treasury c....