Question

Case Scenario: Carrying the Gene Max and Mary are engaged. They are both 23 years old....

Case Scenario: Carrying the Gene

Max and Mary are engaged. They are both 23 years old. A few years ago, when his grandfather became ill, Max discovered that his family carries the gene for Huntington’s disease.

Huntington’s Disease is an adult onset progressively fatal neurological disease. The disease results in the death of brain cells and loss of muscle function. It is characterized by severe, uncoordinated, spontaneous jerking movements of the extremities. Loss of the ability to talk and swallow occur and there is progressive dementia. The gene for Huntington’s disease is a dominant gene, meaning that offspring only need to inherit one gene for the disease to manifest itself.

Max’s father knows that there is a chance that he has inherited the gene but has chosen not to be tested saying, “There’s no treatment anyway, I want to live my life without a sword hanging over my head!” Max, however, believes he should find out his status and if he has the gene for Huntington’s Disease, he believes he should reconsider his upcoming marriage. He is insistent that he doesn’t want to saddle Mary with the responsibility of caring for him when the disease begins to become symptomatic.

Max is also concerned that finding out his status would automatically mean that his dad has the gene as well and will become ill in just a few years. He is concerned because he knows that his father does not want to know his status with regard to the Huntington’s gene, yet Max does not want to hide his own status should he be positive. Max is definitely sure that he doesn’t want to risk passing the Huntington’s gene on to a child and he knows Mary wants children.

Max decides to consult a genetic counselor to help them sort out the complicated issues involved in Max’s decision about whether to have genetic testing for Huntington’s Disease.

Discuss the following:

You are the genetic counselor.

  • What are the ethical issues involved?
  • What ethical principles are in tension in this situation?
  • In your discussion with Max, help him to identify all of the stakeholders.
  • Do you think that there is ethical support for having the test AND not having the test? If so, why? If not, why not?
  • Do you think Mary has a right to this information before they are married? If so, does the genetic counselor have a responsibility to Mary or just to Max?
  • What would you do if you were Max?
  • How would you feel if Max made a decision that is opposite to yours?
0 0
Add a comment Improve this question Transcribed image text
Answer #1

1, To uphold the principle of autonomy, beneficence, nonmaleficence, justice medical professionals should provide more counseling when assessing risk factors of an individual with genetic testing to find Huntington's disease and to strengthen their psychological wellbeing.
2, Medical genetics are principles-based ethics. As a professional, ethical principle in the course of action should be ethics of care, by understanding patient circumstances, needs, feelings, responsiveness as a counselor in this situation by overriding respect for autonomy.
3, Stakeholders' involvement should be in this care are neurologists, psychologists, genetic counselor and medical geneticists.
4, There is ethical support for having the test using the ethic model in this situation by offering predictive test as a counselor our moral responsibility to have a genetic test that helps patient and family to deal with long term consequences of the test which concern with future and the meaning of life.

Add a comment
Know the answer?
Add Answer to:
Case Scenario: Carrying the Gene Max and Mary are engaged. They are both 23 years old....
Your Answer:

Post as a guest

Your Name:

What's your source?

Earn Coins

Coins can be redeemed for fabulous gifts.

Not the answer you're looking for? Ask your own homework help question. Our experts will answer your question WITHIN MINUTES for Free.
Similar Homework Help Questions
  • i need a nursing care plan for this scenario Mary is a 12 month old who...

    i need a nursing care plan for this scenario Mary is a 12 month old who has been vomiting for the past 12 hours. Since waking at 6 AM she has “not held anything down.” It is now 5:30 PM and Mary's father who is caring for the child while his wife is in the hospital ill, is becoming concerned. He calls the primary care office and the nurse recommends that Mary be brought into the office for evaluation. On...

  • i need a nursing intervention for this scenario Background Information: Mary is a 12 month old...

    i need a nursing intervention for this scenario Background Information: Mary is a 12 month old who has been vomiting for the past 12 hours. Since waking at 6 AM she has “not held anything down.” It is now 5:30 PM and Mary's father who is caring for the child while his wife is in the hospital ill, is becoming concerned. He calls the primary care office and the nurse recommends that Mary be brought into the office for evaluation....

  • Scenario Mary Ann, a thirty-two-year-old woman, lives in Clinton, Connecticut with her son, Tony, who is...

    Scenario Mary Ann, a thirty-two-year-old woman, lives in Clinton, Connecticut with her son, Tony, who is eight-years-old, and her boyfriend Jack. Mary Ann also takes care of her mother, Elma, who is elderly and lives with them in their home. Because Jack has trouble holding a job and rarely is employed for more than a few weeks at a time, Mary Ann works as a waitress during the day and as a bartender at night. It is common for her...

  • 1. Mary is a 40-year-old woman who has been diagnosed with schizophrenia. Mary’s 20-year-old daughter, Maria,...

    1. Mary is a 40-year-old woman who has been diagnosed with schizophrenia. Mary’s 20-year-old daughter, Maria, expresses concern that her mother’s mental health disorder is genetic. What is the relationship between genetics and environment in the development of psychiatric disorders? What deficiencies are associated with Mendel’s theory? 6 2. James and Susan have just had their first child. James tells the nurse that he and his wife want to ensure that their new baby’s brain develops to its fullest potential....

  • It was a hot summer day in Fort Myers, Florida, and Max wasanxious to get...

    It was a hot summer day in Fort Myers, Florida, and Max was anxious to get some last-minute surfing in before the end of the weekend. A slip of the knife while prepping dinner had him nursing a minor hand wound that kept him out of the water for the past week. The wound was not very deep and was healing well—it was well scabbed over and was itchy, but painless. After enjoying a full morning back in the surf,...

  • Mr. Parker is an 88-year-old resident of your LTC home with end-stage Alzheimer’s. He is wheelchair bound and spends mos...

    Mr. Parker is an 88-year-old resident of your LTC home with end-stage Alzheimer’s. He is wheelchair bound and spends most of his days sleeping in his wheelchair near a window facing the garden. He needs to be spoon fed but has recently started to refuse to eat. Mr. Parker has three children, one of whom is very involved in the care of her father. The team approaches the daughter about her father refusing to eat, and feels that his refusal...

  • Case scenario Mr. C, 50 years old, is an amateur soccer player who regularly plays with...

    Case scenario Mr. C, 50 years old, is an amateur soccer player who regularly plays with his friends over weekend. He has chronic anterior right hip pain and weakness over his groin region for 5 years. One day, when he was playing soccer, he was injured by another player who crushed on him from lateral side of his left leg. Then, he fell down on the grassland after twisting his left knee and ankle due to the crush. He started...

  • The Case of High Cholesterol Part I Renee and Karl have been married for six years,...

    The Case of High Cholesterol Part I Renee and Karl have been married for six years, and have two active children, ages 2 and 5. The kids keep both parents busy, chasing the kids around and, recently, preparing the oldest child for kindergarten. In addition, both Renee and Karl work full time, so there isn’t a lot of free time to do things that are important to their health, like see the doctor for regular physicals. Both are healthy, so...

  • Elmer and Mary Miller, both 35 years old, liv e with their five children in the...

    Elmer and Mary Miller, both 35 years old, liv e with their five children in the main house on the family farmstead in one of th e largest Amish settlements in Indiana. Aaron and Annie Schlabach, aged 68 and 70, live in the attached grandparents’ cottage. Mary is the youngest of their ei ght children, and when she married, she and Elmer moved into the grandparents’ cottage with the intention that Elmer would take over the farm when Aaron wanted...

  • Mr. Bennet is 60 years old. He teaches grade 5 and loves working with his students....

    Mr. Bennet is 60 years old. He teaches grade 5 and loves working with his students. He was diagnosed with MS at 30 years old, after many years of having symptoms. He has primary progressive MS. He enjoys teaching and hopes he will be able to continue to work in his chosen career until retirement. He is also married and has 4 young grandchildren. He is a hands-on Grandpa. He enjoys reading to his grandchildren and helping them with their...

ADVERTISEMENT
Free Homework Help App
Download From Google Play
Scan Your Homework
to Get Instant Free Answers
Need Online Homework Help?
Ask a Question
Get Answers For Free
Most questions answered within 3 hours.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT