Question



Q5 Your strength can be your weakness A three-person committee has to choose a winner for a national art prize. After some debate, there are three candidates still under consideration: a woman who draws antelope in urban set- tings, a man who makes rectangular lead boxes, and a woman who sculpts charcoal. Lets cal these candidates a, b and c; and call the committee members 1, 2 and 3. The preferences of the nmittee members are as follows: member I prefers a to b and b to c: member 2 prefers c to a and a to b; and member 3 prefers b to c and c to a. The rules of the competition say that, if they disagree, they should vote (secret ballot . one member one vote) and that, if and only if the vote is tied, the winner will be the candidate for whom member ! voted. Thus, it might sem that member I has an advantage
(a) Consider this voting game Each voter has three strategies: a, b, or c. For each voter, which strategies are weakly or strictly dominated? Hints. Be especially careful in the case of voter 1. To answer this question, you do not need to know the exact payofis: any payoffs will do provided that they are consistent with the preference orders given above. To answer this question, you do not have to write out matrices (b) Now consider the reduced game in which all weakly and strictly dominated strategies have been removed. For each voter, which strategies are now weakly or strictly dominated? What is the predicted outcome of the vote? Compare this outcome to voter Is preferences and comment. Hint: When answering this question For player 1, the best response function susefal to construct the best responses for each player lek ke For ezample, if Player and Player & both chose a, then a is the winner no matter what Player 1 does, its best response is to chose anything. In contrast, if Player 2 votes for a and Player 3 votes for b, then Player 1 is better off by voting for a (voting for b or c is strictly worse for Player 1).
0 0
Add a comment Improve this question Transcribed image text
Know the answer?
Add Answer to:
Q5 "Your strength can be your weakness" A three-person committee has to choose a winner for...
Your Answer:

Post as a guest

Your Name:

What's your source?

Earn Coins

Coins can be redeemed for fabulous gifts.

Not the answer you're looking for? Ask your own homework help question. Our experts will answer your question WITHIN MINUTES for Free.
Similar Homework Help Questions
  • Q5 "Your strength can be your weakness" A three-person committee has to choose a winner for...

    Q5 "Your strength can be your weakness" A three-person committee has to choose a winner for a national art prize. After some debate, e are three candidates still under consideration: a woman who draws antelope in urban set- tings, a man who makes rectangular lead boxes, and a woman who sculpts charcoal. Let's call these candidates a, b and e; and call the committee members 1, 2 and 3. The preferences of the nmittee members are as follows: member I...

  • 1. What's the payoff of each situation? 2. How many strategies does each player A and...

    1. What's the payoff of each situation? 2. How many strategies does each player A and B have? A three-person committee has to choose a winner for a national art prize. After some debate, there are three candidates still under consideration: a woman who draws antelope in urban settings, a man who makes rectangular lead boxes, and a woman who sculpts charcoal. Lets call these candidates a, b and c and call the committee members 1, 2 and 3. The...

  • Elections between Hillary and Trump. There are only three voters and all of them strictly prefer...

    Elections between Hillary and Trump. There are only three voters and all of them strictly prefer Hilary to Trump. We assume that voters' utility only depends on the candidate that wins the election. In the first round, all voters vote simultaneously. If a candidate is voted by all the three voters, this candidate is elected. If none of the two candidates receives all the votes, then a second round takes place. All voters vote again simultaneously, but the winner is...

  • To combat election fraud, your city is instituting a new voting procedure. The ballot has a...

    To combat election fraud, your city is instituting a new voting procedure. The ballot has a letter associated with every selection a voter may make. A sample ballot is shown:- (Voter places a tick next to his or her preferred candidate, proposition and measure to indicate his/her vote) 1. Mayoral Candidates     A. Pincher, Penny     B. Dover, Skip     C. Perman, Sue 2. PROP 17     D. YES     E. NO 3. MEASURE 1     F. YES     G....

  • HOMEWORK # 1 (for due date see web page) Consider a simultaneous two-player second-price auction concerning...

    HOMEWORK # 1 (for due date see web page) Consider a simultaneous two-player second-price auction concerning a single indivisible good. The game-frame is as follows: S S ($3, S4, $5, $6, $7 (these are the possible bids), the set of outcomes is the set of pairs (i, p) where ie1,2 is the winner of the auction and p is the price that winner has to pay and the outcome function is as follows (b denotes the bid of Player i):...

ADVERTISEMENT
Free Homework Help App
Download From Google Play
Scan Your Homework
to Get Instant Free Answers
Need Online Homework Help?
Ask a Question
Get Answers For Free
Most questions answered within 3 hours.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT