A paper published in the Harvard Business Review points out a new way to calculate economic profit that could be more appropriate for service firms and other people-intensive companies. Instead of focusing on investment and return on investment, the focus is on employee productivity, both in terms of generating revenues and reducing costs.
The approach is to first determine economic profit in the conventional way, except that we ignore taxes, so that economic profit is before tax, as follows:
Economic profit = Operating profit − Capital charge
Assume the following information for a hotel chain that wishes to adopt the new method. The firm has $100 million in operating profit, has $1 billion in investment, and uses a cost of capital rate of 5%, so the capital charge is $50 million and the economic profit is $50 million. Relevant calculations are contained in Part 1 of the following schedule:
Part 1: Economic Profit (in thousands, except cost of capital rate) | |||
Revenue | $ | 500,000 | |
Operating costs: | |||
Personnel costs | 300,000 | ||
Other costs | 100,000 | ||
Operating profit | $ | 100,000 | |
Operating profit before personnel costs (OPBP) | $ | 400,000 | |
Investment (capital) | $ | 1,000,000 | |
Cost of capital, rate | 0.05 | ||
Capital charge | $ | 50,000 | |
Economic profit = Operating profit − Capital charge | $ | 50,000 | |
Part 2: Economic Profit Calculated Using Employee Productivity | |||
Number of employees | 10,000 | ||
Employee productivity: | |||
Operating profit before personnel cost per employee ($400,000/10,000) | $ | 40 | |
Capital charge per employee ($50,000/10,000) | 5 | ||
Employee productivity | $ | 35 | |
Less personnel cost per employee ($300,000/10,000) | 30 | ||
Economic profit per employee = Productivity − Cost | 5 | ||
Total economic profit, all employees | $ | 50,000 | |
Note: All numbers in thousands except for number of employees | |||
The next step is to decompose economic profit using employee productivity. To do this we first determine operating profit before personnel costs (OPBP):
OPBP | = | Operating profit + Personnel costs |
$400,000 | = | $100,000 + $300,000 |
Employee productivity can be determined by calculating OPBP less capital charge, per employee. For this example, because there are 10,000 employees, OPBP is $40,000 per employee and the capital charge is $5,000 per employee so that productivity is $35,000 per employee. The next step is to determine personnel cost per employee, $30,000, and subtract that from employee productivity to obtain economic profit per employee, $5,000 (i.e., $35,000 – $30,000). Total economic profit for all employees is thus $5,000 × 10,000, or $50 million, the same amount as determined in the conventional way. The value of the decomposition of economic profit into employee productivity and personnel costs per employee is that it provides measures that the hotel chain can benchmark to other hotel chains. It also provides a direct measure of the profit that is being generated per employee relative to the average personnel cost for each employee. Measures of revenue per employee and personnel cost per employee are widely used in the hospital, health and human services, and other people-oriented service industries.
Required:
Use the above approach and assume a chain of residential care facilities employs 10,000 people, has a cost of capital of 5%, and has the following information (000s):
Revenue | $ | 670,000 | |
Operating costs | |||
Personnel costs | 420,000 | ||
Other costs | 150,000 | ||
Operating profit | $ | 100,000 | |
Investment | $ | 1,200,000 | |
Using the newly published method to calculate the productivity, we have, | ||||
Productivity per Employee = | = |
Operating Profit + Personal Costs - Capital Charge |
||
Particulars | Amount | Remarks | ||
Revenue | $ 670,000,000.00 | Given | ||
Operating Costs | ||||
Personal Costs | $ 420,000,000.00 | Given | ||
Other Costs | $ 150,000,000.00 | Given | ||
Operating Profit | $ 100,000,000.00 | Given | ||
Investment | $ 1,200,000,000.00 | Given | ||
Cost of Capital @ 5% | $ 60,000,000.00 | = 5% of Investment Amount | ||
Number of Employees = 10000 | ||||
To dertermine Operating Profits before Personal Costs, we have | ||||
OPBP | = | Operating Profits + Personal Costs | ||
= | $ 520,000,000.00 | |||
OPBP per employee = | OPBP / No. of employees | |||
= 520,000,000 / 10,000 | ||||
$ 52,000.00 | ||||
Capital Charge per employee = | Capital Charge / No. of employees | |||
$ 6,000.00 | ||||
Employee Productivity = | OPBP - Capital Charge per employee | |||
= | $ 46,000.00 | |||
Personal Cost per employee = | Personal Cost / No. of employees | |||
$ 42,000.00 | ||||
Economic Profit per Employee = | Productivity - Personal Costs | |||
= 46,000 - 42,000 | ||||
$ 4,000.00 | ||||
Net Answers | ||||
Productivity per Employee | $ 46,000.00 | |||
Personal Costs per Employee | $ 42,000.00 | |||
Economic Profit per Employee | $ 4,000.00 |
A paper published in the Harvard Business Review points out a new way to calculate economic...
A paper published in the Harvard Business Review points out a new way to calculate economic profit that could be more appropriate for service firms and other people-intensive companies. Instead of focusing on investment and return on investment, the focus is on employee productivity, both in terms of generating revenues and reducing costs. The approach is to first determine economic profit in the conventional way, except that we ignore taxes, so that economic profit is before tax, as follows: Economic...
A paper published in the Harvard Business Review points out a new way to calculate economic profit that could be more appropriate for service firms and other people-intensive companies. Instead of focusing on investment and return on investment, the focus is on employee productivity, both in terms of generating revenues and reducing costs. The approach is to first determine economic profit in the conventional way, except that we ignore taxes, so that economic profit is before tax, as follows: Economic...
PROBLEM #4 Charlotte just finished a year of running her own leather business. During that year, the company generated $400,000 in revenues. The total cost of resources that she bought in the market was $170,000. This broad category includes the costs of raw materials, wages, and computers. The total cost of resources owned by the firm was $65,000. This category includes economic depreciationand foregone interest. Economic depreciation is the fall in market value of a company's capital over a given...
Brad Adams owns Brad’s Baking business. In the previous year, Brad’s baking had the following statement of revenues and cost. Revenues = $300,000 Supplies = $70,000 Utilities = $10,000 Employee salaries = $20,000 Brad’s salary = $30,000 Brad always has an option of closing his baking business and renting out his building for $60,000 per year. Also, Brad has a job offer from a chain baking business offering him a salary of $50,000 per year and a local baking store...
Hitech Ltd acquired all of the issued share capital of Lotech Ltd on 30 June 2016 for a cash consideration of $400,000 At that time the net assets of Lotech Ltd were represented as follows: Share capital 300,000 Retained earnings 50,000 Net assets 350,000 When Hitech acquired its investment in Lotech the following information applied: Land held by Lotech had a fair value $10,000 greater than the carrying value A contingent liability relating to an unsettled legal claim with a...
SandersSanders Manufacturing Company produces electronic components on a job order basis. Most business is gained through bidding on jobs. Most firms competing with SandersSanders bid full cost plus a 3030 % markup. Recently, with the expectation of gaining more sales, SandersSanders dropped its markup from 40% to 3030 %. The company operates two service departments and two production departments. Manufacturing overhead costs and quantities of activities for each department are shown here: LOADING... (Click the icon to view the data.)...
Problem 2 You are considering starting a walk-in clinic. Your financial projections for the first year of operations are as follows” Revenues (10,000 visits) $400,000 Wages and benefits 220,000 Rent 5,000 Depreciation 30,000 Utilities 2,500 Medical supplies 50,000 Administrative supplies 10,000 Assume that all costs are fixed, except medical supplies and administrative supplies, which are variable. Furthermore, assume that the clinic must pay taxes at 30 percent rate. a. Construct the clinic’s projected P&L statement. EXPENSES AMOUNT INCOME AMOUNT Wages...
You have been recently assigned as the new owner representative and asset manager at Capital Hotel Investments, Inc and will oversee 12 hotel properties including the Hilton Garden Inn of Tysons, VA. Following a poor operational 2016 at the Hilton hotel at Tysons, Capital Hotel Investments’ CFO asked you to work with the Hilton’s property management to identify why the hotel’s cash position remains the same despite the realizing $300,000 gain on investments in 2016. The property director of finance...
Suppose a firm doubles the amount of all of its factors of production and, as a result, output increases from 100 to 300 units. This firm is operating under Increasing cost Decreasing costs Long-run decreasing returns Decreasing total cost Diseconomies of scales Positive economic profit is The excess of revenues over implicit costs A signal for firms in other industries to expand their output A signal for resources to enter the industry in the long run The excess of revenues...
S & P Corporation (SPC) is considering entering a new line of business. In alaiyzing business, the financial staff has accumulated the following information: pu The new business will require a capital expenditure of $7 million at t = 0. This expenditure will be used to purchase new equipment. This equipment will be depreciated according to MACRS five-year class (see table on next page). · The equipment will have a salvage value of $500,000 after five years. The required level...