With reference to SCB accountant’s recommendation, critically discuss how Activity Based Costing (ABC) can address the distortions of product costing linked to traditional costing system. You should support your discussion with relevant academic literature.
Ans:
In the field of accounting, activity-based costing and traditional costing are two different methods for allocating indirect (overhead) costs to products.
Both methods estimate overhead costs related to production and then assign these costs to products based on a cost-driver rate. The differences are in the accuracy and complexity of the two methods. Traditional costing is more simplistic and less accurate than ABC, and typically assigns overhead costs to products based on an arbitrary average rate. ABC is more complex and more accurate than traditional costing. This method first assigns indirect costs to activities and then assigns the costs to products based on the products’ usage of the activities.
Traditional Costing Method
Traditional costing systems apply indirect costs to products based on a predetermined overhead rate. Unlike ABC, traditional costing systems treat overhead costs as a single pool of indirect costs. Traditional costing is optimal when indirect costs are low compared to direct costs. There are several steps in the traditional costing process, including the following:
1. Identify indirect costs.
2. Estimate indirect costs for the appropriate period (month, quarter, year).
3. Choose a cost-driver with a causal link to the cost (labor hours, machine hours).
4. Estimate an amount for the cost-driver for the appropriate period (labor hours per quarter, etc.).
5. Compute the predetermined overhead rate (see below).
6. Apply overhead to products using the predetermined overhead rate.
Predetermined Overhead Rate Calculation
Use the following formula to calculate predetermined overhead rate:
Predetermined Overhead Rate = Estimated Overhead Costs / Estimated Cost-Driver Amount
Activity-Based Costing Benefits
Activity based costing systems are more accurate than traditional costing systems. This is because they provide a more precise breakdown of indirect costs. However, ABC systems are more complex and more costly to implement. The leap from traditional costing to activity based costing is difficult.
Traditional Costing Advantages and Disadvantages
Traditional costing systems are simpler and easier to implement than ABC systems. However, traditional costing systems are not as accurate as ABC systems. Traditional costing systems can also result in significant under-costing and over-costing.
Cost Distortions
The Cooper Pen Company example on pages 160-170 illustrates how production volume differences create product cost distortions (See Exhibit 5-1). In their example, the traditional cost system allocates overhead costs using a plant wide rate of 300% of direct labor costs. This causes the high volume products (blue and black pens) to be charged with too much overhead and the low volume products (red and purple pens) to be charged with too little overhead. The reason for these distortions is revealed by the faulty assumption underlying the traditional cost allocation system, i.e., that all overhead costs are driven by production volume, or that the link between cause (driver) and effect (cost) cannot be established. Traditional cost systems treat all overhead costs as unit level costs. However, as ABKY explain, production volume is only one of many cost drivers. A factory producing a large variety of products will have a much greater need for support (e.g., purchasing, scheduling, setup, order tracking and quality control) than a factory that produces a few products.
With reference to SCB accountant’s recommendation, critically discuss how Activity Based Costing (ABC) can address the...
Discuss briefly the activity-based costing (ABC) concept and explain how ABC can differ from traditional costing approaches? Consider a healthcare organization with which you are familiar that uses an ABC model.
Activity-based costing (ABC) or traditional costing do you think is a better approach to costing and why? Be sure to include in your discussion how you think the method you selected is helpful to managers and would benefit the company as a whole.
A Melbourne-based company Acacia is considering the adoption of an activity-based costing (ABC) system because they suspect that their traditional costing system distorts the product costs. Acacia produces and sells two products A and B. Their traditional costing system uses direct labor hours as the allocation base for manufacturing overhead cost. Additional information: Product A Product B Direct materials (DM) $38 per unit $28 per unit Direct labor (DL) $24 per unit $12 per unit Units produced 50,000 units 200,000...
Which method; activity-based costing (ABC) or traditional costing do you think is a better approach to costing and why? Be sure to include in your discussion how you think the method you selected is helpful to managers and would benefit the company as a whole.
You are required to do the following:watch the video below carefully,respond to the discussion question,Video on Activity Based Costing:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cp2ugvDkMP4&t=129sDiscussion Question:“There are two main problems which tend to occur when traditional (simple) costing methods are used to provide information for management decision purposes. These two problems include: (i) product cost distortions, or cross-subsidies; and (ii) the exclusiveness of traditional product costing (i.e. the treatment of non-manufacturing costs differ between traditional cost systems and ABC systems).”Discuss the above statement and explain how...
Explain how ABC (Activity Based Costing) give an accurate evaluation of management performance in comparison to traditional costing method
Suppose an organization uses the activity-based costing (ABC) model. How do you think this model differs from traditional costing approaches? What do you see as advantages or disadvantages for this healthcare organization?
Why Activity-based costing is not relevant and difficult to implement in the service industry? Can you explain specifically why activity-based costing is not relevant? It's hard to understand why ABC is not relevant,thanks
Activity-Based Costing Define activity-based costing (ABC) systems. What benefits does implementing an ABC system bring to the company? Explain at least two benefits. What are the disadvantages to implementing an ABC system? List and explain at least two. Would the proposed changes make ABC a universally applicable costing method in your opinion? Why or why not? Elaborate your response. Non-Financial Performance Many city and county governments are discovering that you can control only what you measure. As a result, many...
True or False: Activity-based costing (ABC) techniques used to evaluate customer profitability can also be applied to evaluating suppliers. True or False: Quality can be defined as the degree to which a product or service performs as it was designed to do. True or False: The basic concepts involved in activity-based costing (ABC) can be used to determine customer profitability as well as product costs. True or False: Tangible customer expectations include how the product's salespeople treat customers and the...