Concept Check: Terminology
Suppose you observe iid samples ?1,…,??∼?
from some unknown distribution ? . Let F denote a
parametric family of probability distributions (for example, F
could be the family of normal distributions
{N(?,?2)}?∈ℝ,?2>0 ).
In the topic of goodness of fit testing, our goal
is to answer the question "Does ? belong
to the family F , or is ? any distribution outside of F
?"
Parametric hypothesis testing is a particular case of goodness of
fit testing (why?). However, in the context of parametric
hypothesis testing, we assume that the data distribution ? comes
from some parametric statistical model {??}?∈Θ ,
and we ask if the distribution ? belongs to a submodel
{??}?∈Θ0 or its complement
{??}?∈Θ1 . In parametric hypothesis testing,
we allow only a small set of alternatives
{??}?∈Θ1 , where as in the goodness of fit
testing, we allow the alternative to be anything.
Categorize the following problems as examples of parameter
estimation, parametric hypothesis testing, or goodness of fit
testing. (Choose all categories that apply.)
Problem 1: Estimate the bias of an unfair coin.
Parameter estimation
Parametric hypothesis testing
Goodness of fit testing unanswered
Problem 2: Decide if a 6-sided die is fair or not.
Parameter estimation
Parametric hypothesis testing
Goodness of fit testing unanswered
Problem 3: Decide if the heights of pine trees in Canada have a
Gaussian distribution. Assume that the statistical model for this
data is {ℝ,Π} where Π denotes the
set of all probability distributions with sample
space ℝ . (In particular, this model is
non-parametric.)
Parameter estimation
Parametric hypothesis testing
Goodness of fit testing
ANSWER:
1)
The probability of heads (or tails) of a given coin is to be estimated here. Thus we are looking for a parameter 'BIAS'. Hence, it is an example of parameter estimation.
Option A is correct.
Parameter hypothesis testing is incorrect because we are not trying to determine if the value of the parameter lies in some specific range of the parametric space.
2)
Here we are interested in TESTING if the probability of each output from 1 to 6 is indeed 1/6 (fair) or not. Thus it is an example of parametric hypothesis testing. Our hypotheses will be that the dice is fair or not fair.
Also, if the dice is fair then the events of getting 1 to 6 will belong to the family of uniform distribution. Hence, it is also an example of goodness of fit testing as we are testing whether the probability distribution belongs to the family of uniform distribution or not.
Options B and C are correct.
3)
It has been specifically mentioned that the model is NON-PARAMETRIC. Thus it cannot belong to either parameter estimation or parametric hypothesis testing.
We just want to know whether the heights of pine trees are a good fit for some distribution of the Gaussian family.
Hence, option C is correct.
If you have any doubts please comment and please don't dislike.
PLEASE GIVE ME A LIKE. ITS VERY IMPORTANT FOR ME.
Concept Check: Terminology Suppose you observe iid samples ?1,…,??∼? from some unknown distribution ? . Let...
Concept Check: Terminology
0/3 points (graded)
Suppose you observe iid samples X1,…,Xn∼P from some
unknown distribution P. Let F denote a parametric
family of probability distributions (for example, F could be the
family of normal distributions {N(μ,σ2)}μ∈R,σ2>0).
In the topic of goodness of fit testing, our
goal is to answer the question "Does P
belong to the family F, or is P
any distribution outside of F
?"
Parametric hypothesis testing is a particular case of goodness
of fit testing...
11. Chi-Squared Test for a Family of Discrete Distributions A Bookmark this page In the problems on this page you will apply the goodness of fit test to determine whether or not a sample has a binomial distribution So far, we have used the x test to determine if our data had a categorical distribution with specific parameters (e.s uniform on an set). element For the problems on this page, we extend the discussion on x tests beyond what was...
Problem 4 True or False A Bookmark this page Instructions: Be very careful with the multiple choice questions below. Some are "choose all that apply," and many tests your knowledge of when particular statements apply As in the rest of this exam, only your last submission will count. 1 point possible (graded, results hidden) The likelihood ratio test is used to obtain a test with non-asymptotic level o True O False Submit You have used 0 of 3 attempts Save...
1. A hypothetical investigation on rider satisfaction with a particular public transit system serving commuting residents of British California (BC) and Prince Edward’s County (PEC) offers some interesting findings. The proportion of commuters from BC that indicated low satisfaction with the transit system’s service in the 2018 calendar year was 65 percent, and the proportion from PEC was 70 percent. These point estimates were based on samples of 5,380 BC commuters and 6,810 PEC commuters, whose system-using commuters number in...