Is there a possible explanation for the apparent equal size of sun and moon or is this a coincidence?
(An explanation can involve something like tide-lock effects or the anthropic principle.)
It just happens to be a coincidence.
The current popular theory for how the Moon formed was a glancing impact on the Earth, late in the planet buiding process, by a Mars sized object. This caused the break up of the impactor and debris from both the impactor and the proto-Earth was flung into orbit to later coallesce into the Moon. So the Moon's size just happens to be random.
Plus the Moon was formed closer to the Earth and due to tidal interactions is slowly drifting away. Over time (astronomical time, millions and millions of years) it will appear smaller and smaller in the sky. It will still always be roughly the size of the Sun but total solar eclipses will become rarer and rarer (they will be more and more annular or partial). Likewise in the past, it was larger and total eclipses were both longer and more common.
The current popular theory for how the Moon formed was a glancing impact on the Earth, late in the planet buiding process, by a Mars sized object. This caused the break up of the impactor and debris from both the impactor and the proto-Earth was flung into orbit to later coallesce into the Moon. So the Moon's size just happens to be random.
Plus the Moon was formed closer to the Earth and due to tidal interactions is slowly drifting away. Over time (astronomical time, millions and millions of years) it will appear smaller and smaller in the sky. It will still always be roughly the size of the Sun but total solar eclipses will become rarer and rarer (they will be more and more annular or partial). Likewise in the past, it was larger and total eclipses were both longer and more common.
oth the moon and the earth's orbits are eccentric, and so the ratio between the sun's and moon's apparent diameter varies with the time of year. When the moon is at perigee, and the earth at aphelion, the moon will seem larger than the sun than when the moon is at apogee and earth at perihelion.
However, the eccentricities of these orbits are low, and the moon always seems "about the same" as the sun. This is a coincidence, both that its size is what it is, and that we're here to observe it. The moon is and will continue to recede from the earth. Eventually, the moon will appear smaller than the sun's disk and won't be able to completely eclipse it anymore.
It seems like this question has its roots in intelligent design (I've heard this argument made in favor of ID before). Were the moon designed to be the same size as the sun's disk, you would think that the earth and moon's orbits wouldn't be eccentric, and that the moon wouldn't gradually receded from the earth, in order to preserve that symmetry.
Is there a possible explanation for the apparent equal size of sun and moon or is...
2. Another application of angular measurement in astronomy is measuring apparent angular size of celestial objects. Complete the follow ing parts a - f of this question. a. Hold a large coin, such as a quarter or half dollar, at arms length and position your self so that it just covers an object in your field of view. Now move the coin toward your eye, does the apparent angular size of the coin increase or decrease? b. Standing in the...
The tidal forces between the Earth and the Moon slowed down the Moon's rotation about its own axis until the rotation period became equal to the Moon's orbital period around the Earth as we observe today. The same effect is also slowing down the Earth's rotation about its own axis and increasing the separation \(D\) between the Moon and the Earth at a rate of \(\Delta D / \Delta t=3.8 \mathrm{~cm}\) per year. In this problem, you can ignore the...
Question 7 (0.5 points) What causes the Moon to move about 12° across the sky from one night to the next (at the same time of night, of course)? O Because the Earth is turning on its axis. O Because the Moon is moving in its orbit. The Sun has also moved 15° across the sky and gravitationally pulls the Moon with it. The celestial sphere the Moon is attached to has moved 15°. O It is an optical illusion....
1.2 Models of Reality Where does the Sun go? At a very young age, infants learn to go from simple observations to mental models of what they are observing. The simplest sort of model is called "object permanence" and just means that something can be hidden or out of sight and still exist. urement? In the case of the Sun rising and setting, this model suggests that it is always the same Sun, which means that the Sun must somehow...
You send a flash of light toward the Moon. It bounces off a mirror and returns to you. You measure the time between when you sent the flash and when it returns to you and find that the whole process took 2.0 seconds. The distance to the Moon is (state your answer in kilometers and list the answer with at least three significant figures.) You can use 3x108 m/s as the speed of light (feel free to google this quantity...
choose correct answer. no explanation needed QUESTION 36 What does the apparent magnitude of a star tell us about that star? its mass how bright it appears from Earth its radius how much energy it is emitting QUESTION 37 What is the reason sunspots appear darker than surrounding regions on the Sun's surface? They actually are fairly bright, but appear dark against the even brighter background of the surrounding photosphere. They are too cold to emit any visible light. They...
A possible means of space flight is to place a perfectly reflecting aluminized sheet into orbit around the Earth and then use the light from the Sun to push this "solar sail." Suppose a sail of area A 5.9010 m2 and mass m 4,800 kg is placed in orbit facing the Sun. Ignore all gravitational effects and assume a solar intensity of 1,370 W/m2 (a) What force (in N) is exerted on the sail? (Enter the magnitude.) 4.47 If you...
For the small population, systemically list all of the possible samples of size n=3 that can be selected by drawing 3 units from 5 with equal probability without replacement. y1 = 6 y2 = 2 y3 = 5 y4 = 12 y5 = 10
A possible means of space flight is to place a perfectly reflecting aluminized sheet into orbit around the Earth and then use the light from the Sun to push this "solar sail." Suppose a sail of area A = 6.40 x 105 m2 and mass m = 7,100 kg is placed in orbit facing the Sun. Ignore all gravitational effects and assume a solar intensity of 1,370 W/m² (a) What force in N) is exerted on the sail? (Enter the...
b. Measure and record the smallest angle i. An object K and an observer at X are formed between lines C and D at E. shown below. Draw a line indicating a line of sight to an object L that lies 35° below object K on the plane of the paper as viewed by the observer at X. c. Based upon the diagram, what is the angle formed at point G between points F and H? j. Below is shown...