Scott’s Dilemma
Scott is a licensed physical therapist who works for a national rehabilitation company. The rehabilitation facility in which Scott works is located in an urban Southwest city. He has worked at this facility for 4 years and until recently was satisfied with his working environment and the interactions he shared with his coworkers. In addition, Scott received personal fulfillment from helping his patients recover from their disabilities and seeing them return to productive lives.
Last year the health system went through reorganization with some new people being brought in and others reassigned. Scott’s new boss, George, was transferred from one of the system’s Midwest facilities. Almost immediately upon taking his new position, George began finding fault
with Scott’s care plans, patient interactions, etc. Scott began feeling as if he couldn’t do anything right. He was experiencing feelings of anxiety, stress, and self-blame. Although his previous performance evaluations had been above average, Scott was shocked by his first performance review under George’s authority—it was an extremely low rating. Scott began trying to work harder, thinking that by working harder he could exceed George’s expectations. Despite the long hours and addressing George’s critiques, George continued to find fault with Scott’s work. Staff meetings began to be a great source of discomfort and stress because George would belittle Scott and single him out in front of his
colleagues.
Scott began to feel alienated from his family, friends, and colleagues at work. His eating and sleeping habits were adversely affected as well. Scott’s activities held no joy for him and the career that he had once loved and been respected in became a source of pain and stress. He began to call in sick more often and started visualizing himself confronting and even hurting George, which created even more guilt and anxiety for Scott. As time went on, George encouraged Scott’s coworkers to leave Scott
alone to do his work. The perception of the coworkers became more sympathetic to George’s point of view. Scott’s coworkers mused that perhaps Scott really was a poor worker and that George knew better due to his position as the supervisor of the rehabilitation department. Eventually, Scott’s coworkers began to distance themselves from him, in order to protect their own interests. They began to see Scott as a outsider, with whom it was unsafe to associate.
In an effort to resolve the situation, Scott spoke to George directly, stating his feelings and expressing an interest in how they might improve the situation. Rather than making the situation better, what George perceived as Scott’s insubordination served to enrage George, and the personal attacks against Scott intensified. Feeling frustrated and helpless, Scott then decided to take his problem to the Human Resources Department (HRD). A human resources manager listened to Scott’s complaints and suggested that Scott return with documented evidence of what Scott perceived to be George’s mistreatment. In an effort to help ease the situation, the HRD manager discussed the issue with George, which only stirred the flames of George’s anger and his negative behavior toward Scott.
As a last resort, Scott decided to go to George’s boss, Rebecca. Rebecca met with George to get his side of the story. George portrayed Scott as an unproductive employee with no respect for authority. The result was a strong letter of reprimand in Scott’s file for insubordination.
1- Discuss the cognitive dissonance reflected in the case as well as the various sources of power. (200 or more words)
2- Describe French and Raven’s five sources of power. What power(s) do the individuals in Scott’s dilemma hold? (200 or more words)
1. The theory of cognitive dissonance is an OB theory which is based on attitude as well as change. The theory throws light on the various conflicts that arise, mainly between attitudes, beliefs and behaviors. These conflicts are the fundamental reason behind the feeling of discomfort and uneasiness in an individual which, eventually pushes him or her, to modify or change any of his attitudes or behaviors.
In the given case, the attitude and perception of George towards Scott had lowered his morale down. George’s perception of Scott was shared among the co-workers and even the attitude of the co-workers had changed about Scott. This is a clear case of cognitive dissonance.
2. French and Raven’s 5 sources of power:
Types of power exhibited in the case are
Scott’s Dilemma Scott is a licensed physical therapist who works for a national rehabilitation company. The...
answer case study questions Case Study 8-2 Scott's Dilemma Scott is a licensed a rehabilitation facility at this facility for four and the interactions be from helping his patien Last year the health syste in and other reassigned west facilities. Almost right. He was experien formance evaluation expectations. Despite Scot d physical therapist who works for a national rehabilitation company. The lity in which Scott works is located in an urban Southwest city. He has worked four years and, up...
CASE-STUDY Jessica Silliman Rachel Bailey was quickly hired out of Santa Clara University during the dot-com boom to a company of 100 employees that ran an innovative social networking website in Silicon Valley. She was immediately put in charge of email communication to customers-both existing and potential. The Internet was quite new to everyone and online communication (via email) had little corporate regulation or set social protocol. Privacy policies were yet to be established. With thousands of individuals discovering the...
I need help with the case W16165 SOMEBODY STOP THE RADIO STAR: JIAN GHOMESHI AT THE CBC Questions: What negative behavior is attributed to Ghomeshi? What was the impact of his alleged behavior on Q employees? Why did the employee get together to compile the red sky presentation for Groen and Noorani? What else could they have done. If is is true that Goneshi treated Q staff extremely poorly over a long period of time (e.g. from April 2007 to...
I need help with the case W16165 SOMEBODY STOP THE RADIO STAR: JIAN GHOMESHI AT THE CBC Questions: What negative behavior is attributed to Ghomeshi? What was the impact of his alleged behavior on Q employees? Why did the employee get together to compile the red sky presentation for Groen and Noorani? What else could they have done. If is is true that Goneshi treated Q staff extremely poorly over a long period of time (e.g. from April 2007 to...
STEP 1: In your own words define problem employees and the categories they may fall into. For the second or last paragraph provide your opinion on which employee type is the most difficult. DEFINITION : I think that "problem employees" are employees that either directly or indirectly hinder the organization's mission or vision, and break down into roughly four categories. In general, problem employees can be classified into two broad categories - employees creating problems for the organization and employees...
THE COMPANY: MORE POWER, INC. More Power, Inc., is a large, local retail store specializing in the sale and service of hardware, tools, lawn and garden implements, and other materials for the home. More Power operates seven days a week, dawn to dusk. Approximately 120 employees work in distinct divisions within the store, including customer service/return desk; warehouse and delivery; service and repair; and three distinct sections focused on (1) hardware and tools, (2) lawn and garden and outdoors, and...
Using the book, write another paragraph or two: write 170 words: Q: Compare the assumptions of physician-centered and collaborative communication. How is the caregiver’s role different in each model? How is the patient’s role different? Answer: Physical-centered communication involves the specialists taking control of the conversation. They decide on the topics of discussion and when to end the process. The patient responds to the issues raised by the caregiver and acts accordingly. On the other hand, Collaborative communication involves a...