Question

Modigliani & Miller show that dividend policy can also be considered irrelevant. Yet, unexpected increases in dividends are often closely followed by price increases, why?

To clarify, when a firm pays a dividend the stock price should drop by the amount of the dividend on the ex-dividend date. Let's say a firm has 5 stockholders, each holding 1 share. The firm owns $2,000 in cash and $3,000 in other assets. So the firm is worth $5,000 (it owes no debt). Each stockholder's claim is worth:

     $5,000/5 = $1000.

Now the firm declares a dividend of $100/share. They must pay out a total of: $100 x 5shares = $500. So after the dividend is paid the firm now has $1,500 in cash and $3,000 in other assets, for a total of $4,500. Dividing this by 5 stockholders, we find that each stockholders claim is $900. The same as if we take $1,000 less $100 dividend to get $900. The stockholder hasn't lost anything, he still has $1,000 in value, just $900 in the firm and $100 in cash now.

But what we actually often see in practice is:

Let’s say the firm was expected to pay a $100/share dividend, but instead pays a dividend of $110. Like the example above, we would expect to see the stockholder's value fall to $890 ($1,000 - $110 = $890). Again, the stockholder still has $1,000; $890 in the firm and $110 in cash. In practice though, we see that instead of the stock dropping to $890, it falls to say, only $895. Thus the stockholder's value is now; $110 + $895 = $1,005.

Why did they gain $5 in value, just by issuing the dividend?

Answer 1

Given dala 100 x5hares the steck's pfce should alvep perket mo kes, aning (ueriy amourt n on t ex-deidend date Tn dulaved dfvidend dud ther econonic actovs aed hebehaviour of tho day expecked e-diidend Raelie, Un cerhinty ealence in Conelusive hexrdividened dvidened day on th Yo-tionale r thehaviaur. "htus, Pice dnp ond dividend shave do r necesaiy have to be egual Aceding salay PoweY and isk f ts assets to M&M ky caving determine value f tho -firm. MaM als arque that shavehelders CYeate ey fndiflerent to th poyment of ddnds berouse Can ave shaves of thstocks. This shavelalcdey's dwdend poliytheydesve hy bag or ing mcon thal ooend pliay hai vo efferl on Contvovevsial Condlusion usealth onclude that though vaue of teshock aeemomic factors tvalue of. tk strk leer aumoun than tamountto b dhefpeo drop to890, we Can pracke dlue to tha dnp by a dividend Patd. Tha is may intvease uhy thy gon5 n value.