Question

Show, by Minkowski diagrams, that (1) time-like events can occur at the same position, but not...

Show, by Minkowski diagrams, that (1) time-like events can occur at the same position, but not at the same time, (2) space-like events can occur at the same time, but not at the same position, (3) space-like events can have any order/sequence.

0 0
Add a comment Improve this question Transcribed image text
Answer #1

I'll do the whole analysis in c=1 units.

(1) Consider the following Minkowski diagram. Forget about the blue lines and the t'-x' axis. Focus on the events A and B. Convince yourself that events A and B are time-like and they occur at different times and positions in x-t frame. The dashed line is the 45 degree line corresponding to speed of light, which is 1.

Now consider a boost in the +ve x direction. In x-t frame the x'-t' line move towards each other (they actually are orthogonal in their own frame) and are represented by blue lines. Note that these are the lines that an observer in x-t frame will draw. So the observer just has to find the right line that passes through the A and B events, which will become the t' axis. Clearly, events A and B have the same x' coordinate (x'=0), which is exactly what we wanted. For A and B to occur at the same time we will need an x'-axis to pass through them, but this can't happen because we can't move faster than light!

(2)Something similar is to happen here as well. This time we just need to find an x'-axis which passes through A and B and it is possible for space-like events only. In x'-t' frame both A and B occur at t'=0, which is what we wanted. Again they can't occur at same positions because it is impossible to cross the c=1 barrier.

(3) In part (2) if we go a little faster, then A and B would reverse order. For simplicity, consider the event B at origin O. The red lines correspond to x"-t" frame which is even faster than x'-t' frame. The following can be concluded for space-like events OA

\begin{align*} t_A>0\\ t'_A=0\\ t''_A<0 \end{align*}

Add a comment
Know the answer?
Add Answer to:
Show, by Minkowski diagrams, that (1) time-like events can occur at the same position, but not...
Your Answer:

Post as a guest

Your Name:

What's your source?

Earn Coins

Coins can be redeemed for fabulous gifts.

Not the answer you're looking for? Ask your own homework help question. Our experts will answer your question WITHIN MINUTES for Free.
Similar Homework Help Questions
  • 1. Time-Like, Null, and Space-like Intervals Events E, F, and G in an inertial reference frame...

    1. Time-Like, Null, and Space-like Intervals Events E, F, and G in an inertial reference frame have (t, z) coordinates as follows, Note that we're measuring both space and time coordinates in consistent units, i.e. (a) (4 points) Draw a spacetime diagram with the three points marked and labeled. (i) Is the interval between the two events time-like, null, or space-like? seconds and light-seconds, or light-metres (a unit of time!) and metres. Answer the following questions for the pair of...

  • Two events are observed in a frame of reference S to occur at the same space...

    Two events are observed in a frame of reference S to occur at the same space point, with the second event occurring after a time of 1.70 s . In a second frame S' moving relative to S, the second event is observed to occur after a time of 2.25 s . What is the difference between the positions of the two events as measured in S'? Use 3.00×108 m/s for the speed of light in a vacuum.

  • Two events occur in an inertial system at the same time, but 8445 km apart. However...

    Two events occur in an inertial system at the same time, but 8445 km apart. However in another inertial system these two events are observed to be 11210 km apart. What is the time difference between the two events in this second inertial system? Submit Answer Tries 0/12

  • Two time-like separated events in spacetime have coordinates in the lab frame S given by (ch,...

    Two time-like separated events in spacetime have coordinates in the lab frame S given by (ch, x) = (1,1) and (a) How fast must S' be moving so that events 1 and 2 happen at the same point in space (i.e, their x coordi- (b) If S' is moving at speed u = 0.9c, how far separated in time (equivalently the coordinate cr) are the two (c) How fast must S be moving so that events 1 and 2 are...

  • 4-1 Two events occur at the same place in a certain inertial frame and are separated...

    4-1 Two events occur at the same place in a certain inertial frame and are separated by a time interval of 4 sec. What is the spatial separation between these two events in an inertial frame in which the events are separated by a time interval of 6 sec?

  • (1) Sequence diagrams represent    (a) exactly what the use case diagram represents.    (b) the...

    (1) Sequence diagrams represent    (a) exactly what the use case diagram represents.    (b) the sequence for a scenario of a use case.    (c) exactly what the class diagram represents.    (d) the sequences that connect multiple use cases together. (2) Actors in a sequence diagram typically interact with    (a) Boundary objects    (b) Entity objects    (c) Any type of object    (d) Control objects (3) Are sequence and communication diagrams different from one another?   ...

  • The space and time coordinates for two events as measured in a frame S are as...

    The space and time coordinates for two events as measured in a frame S are as follows: Event 1: x1=x0, t1=x0/c Event 2 : x2=2x0, t1=x0/2c (a) There exists a frame in which these events occur at the same time. Find the velocity of this frame with respect to S. (b) What is the value of t at which both events occur in the new frame?

  • Be DETAILED and show everything that needs to be labeled and included. On the same screen...

    Be DETAILED and show everything that needs to be labeled and included. On the same screen of your iPad, or the same side of a sheet of paper, make side-by-side diagrams of a mitochondrion and a chloroplast. The main point in the diagram is to show where major processes occur relative to membranes. Using fine lines (no fat markers) label the diagrams, clearly and precisely, with the locations of: 1) Each membrane 2) Each space (for example, the intermembrane space,...

  • On the same screen of your iPad, or the same side of a sheet of paper,...

    On the same screen of your iPad, or the same side of a sheet of paper, make side-by-side diagrams of a mitochondrion and a chloroplast. The main point in the diagram is to show where major processes occur relative to membranes. Using fine lines (no fat markers) label the diagrams, clearly and precisely, with the locations of: 1) Each membrane 2) Each space (for example, the intermembrane space, the matrix, ...) 3) The H+ gradients (be clear on where high...

  • 3. Two different events can occur called A and B. The probability that A occurs is...

    3. Two different events can occur called A and B. The probability that A occurs is 0.90, the probability that B is 0.70, while the probability that both occur is 0.65. Are the two events independent? What is the probability that either of the events occurs? If B occurs, what is the probability that A will occur? Sixty four athletes are to compete for an Olympic event. How many distinct ways can the three medals, gold, silver, and bronze be...

ADVERTISEMENT
Free Homework Help App
Download From Google Play
Scan Your Homework
to Get Instant Free Answers
Need Online Homework Help?
Ask a Question
Get Answers For Free
Most questions answered within 3 hours.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT