Question

Come-Clean Corporation produces a variety of cleaning compounds and solutions for both industrial and household use. While most of its products are processed independently, a few are related, such as the company's Grit 337 and its Sparkle silver polish. Grit 337 is a coarse cleaning powder with many industrial uses. It costs $1.20 a pound to make, and it has a selling price of $7.20 a pound. A small portion of the annual production of Grit 337 is retained in the factory for further processing. It is combined with several other ingredients to form a paste that is marketed as Sparkle silver polish. The silver polish sells for $5.00 per jar. This further processing requires one-fourth pound of Grit 337 per jar of silver polish. The additional direct variable costs involved in the processing of a jar of silver polish are: Other ingredients Direct labor Total direct cost $ 0.55 1.44 $ 1.99 Overhead costs associated with processing the silver polish are: 25% of direct labor cost Variable manufacturing overhead cost Fixed manufacturing overhead cost (per month) Production supervisor Depreciation of mixing equipment $3,400 $1,500 The production supervisor has no duties other than to oversee production of the silver polish. The mixing equipment is special- purpose equipment acquired specifically to produce the silver polish. It can produce up to 7,000 jars of polish per month. Its resale value is negligible and it does not wear out through use. Advertising costs for the silver polish total $2,600 per month. Variable selling costs associated with the silver polish are 5% of sales. Due to a recent decline in the demand for silver polish, the company is wondering whether its continued production is advisable. The sales manager feels that it would be more profitable to sell all of the Grit 337 as a cleaning powder.
CORRECT the WRONG answers

Answer 1

Solution 1:

Revenue per Jar of silver polish = $5 per jar

Revenue per 1/4th pound of Grit 337 = $7.20 / 4 = $1.80

Incremental revenue per jar for further processing = $5 - $1.80 = $3.20 per jar

Solution 2:

Computation of Additional contribution Margin- If Grit 377 sold after further processing
Particulars	Grit 377 per 1/4 Pound	Silver Polish per jar	Net Increase/ (decrease)
Selling price per unit	$1.80	$5.00	$3.20
Variable Costs:
Making cost of Grit 337	$0.30	$0.30	$0.00
Other ingredients	$0.00	$0.55	$0.55
Direct labour	$0.00	$1.44	$1.44
Variable Manufacturing Overhead	$0.00	$0.36	$0.36
Variable Selling Cost	$0.00	$0.25	$0.25
Total variable costs	$0.30	$2.90	$2.60
Contribution margin	$1.50	$2.10	$0.60

Hence incremental contribution per jar for further processing = $0.60 per jar

Solution 3:

Minimum number of jars of silver polish that must be sold each month = Avoidabe fixed cost / incremental contribution margin per jar

= ($3400+$2600) / $0.60 = 10,000 jars

Solution 4:

If company sells 8400 jars of polish then incremental contribution margin of further processing = 8400 * $0.60 = $5,040

Avoidable fixed cost = $3400 + 2600 = $6,000

Financial advantage (disadvantage) of further processing = $5,040 - $6,000 = ($960)

Solution 5:

If company sells 11200 jars of polish then incremental contribution margin of further processing = 11200 * $0.60 = $6,720

Avoidable fixed cost = $6,000

Financial advantage (disadvantage) of further processing = $6,720 - $6,000 = $720