Question

5. We have three alternatives. Costs, benefits, RoR and years are as bellows. Using EUAnnuity Benefit and Cost which is the b
0 0
Add a comment Improve this question Transcribed image text
Answer #1
Alpha
Years Benefits PVF @ 10% Present Value
0 -600 1 =+B3*C3
1 158.3 =1/1.1 =+B4*C4
2 158.3 =+C4/1.1 =+C5*B5
3 158.3 =+C5/1.1 =+C6*B6
4 158.3 =+C6/1.1 =+C7*B7
5 158.3 =+C7/1.1 =+C8*B8
NPV =SUM(D3:D8)
Beta
Years Benefits PVF @ 10% Present Value
0 -500 1 =+B14*C14
1 139.7 =1/1.1 =+B15*C15
2 139.7 =+C15/1.1 =+B16*C16
3 139.7 =+C16/1.1 =+B17*C17
4 139.7 =+C17/1.1 =+B18*C18
5 139.7 =+C18/1.1 =+B19*C19
NPV =SUM(D14:D19)
Gamma
Years Benefits PVF @ 10% Present Value
0 -200 1 =B25*C25
1 58.3 =1/1.1 =B26*C26
2 58.3 =+C26/1.1 =B27*C27
3 58.3 =+C27/1.1 =B28*C28
4 58.3 =+C28/1.1 =B29*C29
5 58.3 =+C29/1.1 =B30*C30
NPV =SUM(D25:D30)

File S S - Home Insert Page Layout For * Cut Calibri 11 E Copy Format Painter BIU... > Clipboard Font Paste E4 ДА В с р Alpha

File Home Insert Page Layout Formulas * Cut Calibri 11 - Á À Еe Copy - Paste Format Painter BIU - - .A Clipboard Font Data =

Since the NPV of Gamma is more than Alpha & Beta , Gamma is the Best one to select.

We can also Calculate Benefit to Cost Ratio (BCR) - Total Benefits / Total Cost

Total Cost + NPV = Total Benefit

Aplha

Total benefit- 600+0.08 = 600.08

Total Cost= 600

BCR= 600.08/600

= 1.001 (Approx)

Beta

Total Benefit = 500+29.7 = 529.7

Total Cost = 500

BCR = 529.7/500

=1.059 (Approx)

Gamma

Total Benefit= 200+21 = 221

Total Cost = 200

BCR= 221/200

=1.105 (Approx)

Since BCR of Gamma is more it is most beneficial.

Add a comment
Know the answer?
Add Answer to:
5. We have three alternatives. Costs, benefits, RoR and years are as bellows. Using EUAnnuity Benefit...
Your Answer:

Post as a guest

Your Name:

What's your source?

Earn Coins

Coins can be redeemed for fabulous gifts.

Not the answer you're looking for? Ask your own homework help question. Our experts will answer your question WITHIN MINUTES for Free.
Similar Homework Help Questions
ADVERTISEMENT
Free Homework Help App
Download From Google Play
Scan Your Homework
to Get Instant Free Answers
Need Online Homework Help?
Ask a Question
Get Answers For Free
Most questions answered within 3 hours.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT