MARR = 12%
Net annual revenue = 300000 - 100000 = 200000
1. Let ROR be I%, then
- 1200000 + 200000 * (P/A, I%,10) + 400000 * (P/F, I%,10) = 0
dividing by 200000
- 6 + (P/A, I%,10) + 2 * (P/F, I%,10) = 0
(P/A, I%,10) + 2 * (P/F, I%,10) = 6
After this we need to use trail and error method and interpolation to find ROR
2 & 3. Using RATE & IRR function in Excel
Year | Investment | Revenue | Cost | Salvage value | Net Cash Flow |
0 | -1200000 | -1200000 | |||
1 | 300000 | -100000 | 200000 | ||
2 | 300000 | -100000 | 200000 | ||
3 | 300000 | -100000 | 200000 | ||
4 | 300000 | -100000 | 200000 | ||
5 | 300000 | -100000 | 200000 | ||
6 | 300000 | -100000 | 200000 | ||
7 | 300000 | -100000 | 200000 | ||
8 | 300000 | -100000 | 200000 | ||
9 | 300000 | -100000 | 200000 | ||
10 | 300000 | -100000 | 400000 | 600000 | |
ROR Using RATE Function | 13.06% | ||||
ROR Using IRR Function | 13.06% |
As ROR using RATE and IRR function is greater than MARR (12%), therefore project is acceptable
Showing formula in Excel
Year | Investment | Revenue | Cost | Salvage value | Net Cash Flow |
0 | -1200000 | =I12+J12+K12+L12 | |||
1 | 300000 | -100000 | =I13+J13+K13+L13 | ||
2 | 300000 | -100000 | =I14+J14+K14+L14 | ||
3 | 300000 | -100000 | =I15+J15+K15+L15 | ||
4 | 300000 | -100000 | =I16+J16+K16+L16 | ||
5 | 300000 | -100000 | =I17+J17+K17+L17 | ||
6 | 300000 | -100000 | =I18+J18+K18+L18 | ||
7 | 300000 | -100000 | =I19+J19+K19+L19 | ||
8 | 300000 | -100000 | =I20+J20+K20+L20 | ||
9 | 300000 | -100000 | =I21+J21+K21+L21 | ||
10 | 300000 | -100000 | 400000 | =I22+J22+K22+L22 | |
ROR Using RATE Function | =RATE(10,200000,-1200000,400000) | ||||
ROR Using IRR Function | =IRR(M12:M22) |
Question 1 (6pts). For the cash flows shown below, answer the following questions. (Assume MARR =...
anyone can check my answer? Student Name: QUID: Section: Question 1 (6pts). For the cash flows shown below, answer the following questions. (Assume MARR = 15% (1) (2pts) Provide the equation using PW to find the ROR of the cash flow given. (2) (2pts) Decide whether the project is acceptable or not using RATE function in MS Excel. Provide the screenshot (3) (2pts) Decide whether the project is acceptable or not using IRR_function in MS Excel. Provide the screenshot Year...
very important Question 2 (4pts). For the cash flows shown below, decide whether the project is acceptable or not using IRR function in MS Excel (Assume MARR -10%). Provide the screenshot Year First cost (S) Revenue (S) M&O cost (5) Salvage (5) 0 1,000,000 300,000 100.000 200,000 400,000 100,000 300,000 500.000 200.000 200.000 Refer to the Screenshot Guideline in the next page Note: 1. Attach this page (this introduction page) as the cover page. 2. Copy and paste the screenshot...
Question 9: Consider the following cash flow profile and assume MARR is 10%/year. 0 1 L End of Year Cash Flow -50 18 18 18 18 18 a. What does Descartes' rule of signs tell us about the IRR (s) of this project? b. What does the Norstrom's criterion tell us about the IRR (s) of this project? c. Determine the IRR for this project. Is this project economically attractive based on the IRR? d. Determine the ERR for this...
Question 10: Consider the following cash flow profile and assume MARR is 12%/year. 0 1 2 3 End of Year Cash Flow -1000 3400 -5700 3800 a. What does Descartes' rule of signs tell us about the IRR (8) of this project? b. What does the Norstrom's criterion tell us about the IRR (s) of this project? c. Determine the ERR for this project. Is this project economically attractive?
1. Which alternative of the three alternatives below should be selected if the MARR = 6%? Use the following to compare projects: PW analysis B/C ratio for each project Incremental B/C ratio assessment IRR for each project over its respective service life Incremental IRR using the same (a common) number of years for each project Are any of the projects acceptable? Are any not acceptable? Which project would you recommend and why? Alternatives: A B C First Cost $800 $300 ...
14. Consider four projects with the following sequences of cash flows: n 0 NET CASH FLOWS A B C -$25,000|-$23,000-$56,500 $12,000 $32,000 -$2,500 $23,000 $32,000-$6,459 $34,000 $25,000 $88,345 3 (a) Identify all the simple investments. (b) Identify all the non-simple investments. (c) Compute the Internal Rate of Return (IRR) for each project using NPV method and Excel. Note the following: A simple (or conventional) investment is simply when one sign change occurs in the net cash flow series. If the...
Consider the following cash flows of two mutually exclusive projects for a company. Assume the discount rate for the company is 10 percent. (5pts) Year A B 0 -$1,400,000 -$600,000 1 900,000 300,000 2 800,000 500,000 3 700,000 400,000 a. Based on the payback period, which project should be taken? b. Based on the NPV, which project should be taken? c. Based on IRR, which project should be taken? d. Based on this analysis, is incremental IRR analysis necessary? If...
Problem 1. Three alternative projects with infinite lives are under consideration. Initial costs and cash flows of each project are shown. MARR is 15% per year. a) Which alternatives will be selected if projects are independent based on ROR analysis? b) Which alternatives will be selected if projects are mutually exclusive based ROR analysis? Show your solution in both cases of a) and b) (Note: A=Pi for infinite n) (You may set PW=0 or AW=0 to find i) Alternatives Initial...
1. Find an internal rate of return (IRR) for these cash flows. 2. Should you use the IRR you calculated in the previous question to decide whether the project is acceptable? Explain Please show all work. Thank you! Use the following information to answer the next two questions. Consider the after-tax cash flows below: Year O 1 2 3 4 Cash Flow -$75,000| $5,3001 -$1,300 $498,000-$336,000 The required rate of return is 13.6 percent.
#14 the following information to answer questions 14 through 18. Assume Do-Nothing is an option. MARR-10% Alternative #1 Alternative #2 $205,000 $43,000 in year 1, First Cost $100,000 $35,000 per year increase of $3,000 per year S5,000 per years $10,000 per year Benefits O&M Costs Salvage Value for each of the following years $10,000 Useful Life ROR S15,000 8 years 10.85% 14. The NPW of Alternative #1 (necessary to make a decision between the two alternative) is closest to a)...