Q1) Using AW method compare between the following alternatives: (6 marks) Alt. F.C. Operating and Income at the Annual S.V. Useful life i. maintenance nd end of 2 year Income А 35000 0 3500 2800 7000 8 8% B 32000 1500 4700 2500 0 8%
Answer: Select Alternative B
Annual Worth of Alternative A is -2109.90
Annual Worth of Alternative B is -1237.66
Explanation:
Compute Annual Worth
Alternative A
AW(A) = -35000 * (A/P, 8%, 8) + 3500 * (P/F, 8%, 2) * (A/P, 8%, 8) + 2800 + 7000 * (A/F, 8%, 8)
Compute (A/P, i%, n) using [i * (1 + i)n] / [(1 + i)n - 1]
(A/P, 8%, 8) = [0.08 * (1 + 0.08)8] / [(1 + 0.08)8 - 1] = [0.08 * (1.08)8] / [(1.08)8 - 1]
= [0.08 * 1.8509] / [1.8509 - 1] = 0.1740
Compute (P/F, i%, n) using (1 + i)(-n)
(P/F, 8%, 2) = (1 + 0.08)(-2) = (1.08)(-2)= 0.8573
Compute (A/F, i%, n) using i / [(1 + i)n - 1]
(A/F, 8%, 8) = 0.08 / [(1 + 0.08)8 - 1] = 0.08 / [(1.08)8 - 1] = 0.08 / [1.8509 - 1] =0.0940
AW(A) = (-35000 * 0.1740) + (3500 * 0.8573 * 0.1740) + 2800 + (7000
* 0.0940) = -2109.90
Annual Worth of Alternative A is -2109.90
Alternative B
AW(B) = [-32000 + 4700 * (P/F, 8%, 2)] * 0.08 - 1500 + 2500
= [-32000 + (4700 * 0.8573)] * 0.08 - 1500 + 2500
= -27970.69 * 0.08 - 1500 + 2500 = -1237.66
Annual Worth of Alternative B is -1237.66
Annual Worth of Alternative B is higher.
Select Alternative B
Q1) Using AW method compare between the following alternatives: (6 marks) Alt. F.C. Operating and Income at the Annual S.V. Useful life i. maintenance nd end of 2 year Income А 35000 0 3500 2800 7000 8 8% B 32000 1500 4700 2500 0 8%