Question

Which analogical argument is stronger?

Walnuts, hickory nuts, and pecans are high in protein. Consequently, almonds are probably high in protein.

Walnuts are high in protein. Consequently, almonds are probably high in protein.

Answer 1

Yhe first argument , I.e. Walnuts, hickory nuts, and pecans are high in protein. Consequently, almonds are probably high in protein. Is stronger than the 2nd argument that Walnuts are high in protein. Consequently, almonds are probably high in protein because in first argument premise , there are more items whose features are being used to reach a conclusion by apology.