Question

You've got another difficult problem to solve. However, now that you've had some experience using the lenses, we know that you can sort your way through this second problem.

As you remember, the second step in making an ethical decision is Being Intelligent. As you reflect on the communications from the previous screen, use your critical thinking skills to evaluate the facts and each person's emotional state to figure out exactly what ethical values are in tension with each other. Then, you'll be able to frame the issue as a statement that clearly highlights the ethical tension.

Remember that the best statement of the issue will...

• Highlight the tension between two competing values.
• Focus on whether the outcome would help everyone achieve their highest ethical goals instead of just taking care of yourself.
• Avoid focusing on a specific course of action. Choosing exactly what you're going to do too early defeats the purpose of analysis.
• Avoid focusing on yourself to avoid an unpleasant outcome. Being ethically mature involves considering the expectations of all of the people involved, even if you face some risks.

If you want some additional background in framing ethical issues, click on the book icon at the top of this page. Remember that the Ethics Coach playbook changes on each page with information that may give you a clearer picture of the task you are facing.

As you are Being Intelligent, select the statement that best represents the values that are in tension in the ethical dilemma. Then click Next at the bottom of the page.

Which issue frames the values in tension?

A. Whether G-BioSport should attempt to involve the Slovanian government agency responsible for local environmental matters as a participant in negotiations to solve this problem.

B. Whether G-BioSport should procure OSL from a U.S. source in order to promote more environmentally sustainable production practices and the employment of U.S. workers.

C. Whether G-BioSport should seek out a solution to the pollution issue with Bresnet that considers the interests of key stakeholders beyond G-BioSport's shareholders.

D. Whether G-BioSport can rely on Bresnet's compliance with its local environmental laws and regulations as the basis for continuing to do business with Bresnet.

Answer 1

Which issue frames the values in tension?

A. Whether G-BioSport should attempt to involve the Slovenian government agency responsible for local environmental matters as a participant in negotiations to solve this problem. - Correct Answer

Explanation: We attempt to bring in other parties that can provide a neutral stand. This will mean that all stakeholders and shareholders will be in the clear because neither parties need to provide assurance when there is a government agency is involved. The government agency is the third party. There is no chance to look out for personal interests. This is not specific but just opens up avenues for discussion.