Question

The Soul Callers Chant ipg Fadiman concludes her book with the above words chanted by the tiv neeb during a soul calling ceremony for Lia Lee. These words are both poignant and lyrical The Hmong people consider disease to be spiritually-based while American health professionals view it as caused by physical alterations What might American health professionals learn froma tr neeb?is it appropriate to advocate for spirtiual interventions in the American health system for those who desire them? Why or why not? Support your argument with the literature You are not required to post responses to your peers. This is a single post discussion. Your post will be evaluated based on completeness of answering the three questions and your ability to support your opinion with evidence.

Answer 1

Txiv Neeb ,the shaman who is a person regarded as having access to and influence in the world of good and evil spirits. It is there at the centre of Hmong culture.According to Hmong cosmology, the human body is the host for a number of souls.The isolation and separation of one or more of these souls from the body can cause disease , depression, death.

Modern medicine demands collaboration between technology based western medical ideologies and the cultural and spiritual beliefs and practices of a multicultural nation, thus humanizing medicine.The Hmong have a holistic approach to healing, they heal the soul and the flesh ..Each one is not mutually exclusive . The Hmong believe that when soul.is not well it is often manifested as physical ailments.It is true as mental disturbances can affect body and any bodily disease affects peaceful mind also. The txiv beeb fuses the dichotomy of illness and disease and therefore validates the patients concerns.In effect the neeb conducts very effective session of psychological therapy. Thus modern doctors also need to take that patient needs us and require detailed case taking and enquiry in to their problems which itself provide them with confidence and reassurance. Western medicine is often one sided and claims to be right.If we bringcompassion and faith also in to our practice .