Question

1.     Computing ROE and ROA: Both ROA and ROE measure profitability. Which one is more useful for...

1.     Computing ROE and ROA: Both ROA and ROE measure profitability. Which one is more useful for comparing two companies? Why?

2.     (Graded) Ratio Analysis: Consider the ratio EBITD/Assets. What does this ratio tell us? Why might it be more useful than ROA in comparing two companies?

3.     Return on Investment: A ratio that is becoming more widely used is return on investment. Return on investment is calculated as net income divided by long-term liabilities plus equity. What do you think return on investment in intended to measure? What is the relationship between return on investment and return on asset?

0 0
Add a comment Improve this question Transcribed image text
Answer #1

1.     Computing ROE and ROA: Both ROA and ROE measure profitability. Which one is more useful for comparing two companies? Why?

ROE is Net income/Average equity and ROA = EBIT*(1-t)/Average total assets.

While ROE measures return on shareholders' funds ROA measures return on total assets, which is equal to total funds supplied by creditors and shareholders.

ROA is more appropriate in comparing two companies.

The reason is that ROE is based on 'after tax income after providing for interest on debt' and on 'funds supplied excluding debt'.

As the quantum of interest, which in turn is based on each company's financing policy with respect to its capital structure, can differ widely between firms, ROE does not a reflect the relative operating efficiency of the firms.

In contrast, the ROA measures the efficiency of a firm in using its total resources (total assets) and is not affected by the extent of financial leverage. Hence, the ROA is more appropriate in comparing the profitability of firms.

2.     (Graded) Ratio Analysis: Consider the ratio EBITD/Assets. What does this ratio tell us? Why might it be more useful than ROA in comparing two companies?

The ratio expresses the 'earnings before interest taxes and depreciation' as percentage of total assets.

The ratio is an improvement over the ROA, which uses NOPAT in the numerator.

EBITDA excludes taxes and depreciation also, in addition to excluding interest.

The exclusion of depreciation and taxes provides refinements to make the ratio more comparable between firms.

The first is that it converts the income on cash basis by excluding the non cash item of depreciation.

Secondly, difference in depreciation methods and the aging of the assets will affect the quantum of depreciation, and by removing depreciation expense, the profit parameter becomes more comparable.

Finally, tax effect could be different on different companies due to the tax structure, which is also eliminated.

Return on Investment: A ratio that is becoming more widely used is return on investment. Return on investment is calculated as net income divided by long-term liabilities plus equity. What do you think return on investment in intended to measure? What is the relationship between return on investment and return on asset?

Return on investment is intended to measure the return on capital employed or return on net operating assets. Current liabilities that do not bear interest, are deducted from total operating assets.

Hence, while return on assets reflects the return on total assets (total funds invested), return on investment reflects the return on net operating assets (funds for which there is a cost) only.

Add a comment
Know the answer?
Add Answer to:
1.     Computing ROE and ROA: Both ROA and ROE measure profitability. Which one is more useful for...
Your Answer:

Post as a guest

Your Name:

What's your source?

Earn Coins

Coins can be redeemed for fabulous gifts.

Not the answer you're looking for? Ask your own homework help question. Our experts will answer your question WITHIN MINUTES for Free.
Similar Homework Help Questions
  • Profitability ratios reflect the net result of all the firm's erect. B policies and operating decisions....

    Profitability ratios reflect the net result of all the firm's erect. B policies and operating decisions. The profitability ratios include the: (1) Operating profit margin, (2) Net profit margin, (3) Return on total assets (ROA), (4) Basic earning power (BEP) ratio, and (5) Return on common equity (ROE). The operating profit margin indicates what percentage of sales remain after et B are accounted for. It is a measure of the firm's operating effidency. Its equation is: B. It measures the...

  • TRUE/FALSE 1) The return on total assets ratio is not a profitability measure. 1) 2) The...

    TRUE/FALSE 1) The return on total assets ratio is not a profitability measure. 1) 2) The return on total assets can be calculated as profit margin divided by total asset turnover. 2) 3) A company that has days' sales uncollected of 30 days and days' sales in inventory of 18 days implies that inventory will be converted to cash in about 12 days. 3) 4) The higher the accounts receivable turnover, the less quickly accounts receivable are collečted.4) 5) Efficiency...

  • 1 AAPL has lower ROE than CSCO. Both companies have very similar ROA. Which of the...

    1 AAPL has lower ROE than CSCO. Both companies have very similar ROA. Which of the following much be true?   a) AAPL has lower debt to total asset than CSCO. b) AAPL is better at managing assets than CSCO c) AAPL has higher debt to equity than CSCO. d) AAPL has lower debt to equity than CSCO. 2) CrazyBoy Burger Inc. has total assets at the end of last year were $415,000 and its net income was $32,750. What was...

  • 8.2 The coefficient of variation is a better measure of stand-alone risk than standard deviation because...

    8.2 The coefficient of variation is a better measure of stand-alone risk than standard deviation because it is a standardized measure of risk per unit; it is calculated as the -Select- divided by the expected return. The coefficient of variation shows the risk per unit of return, so it provides a more meaningful risk measure when the expected returns on two alternatives are not -Select- .. The Sharpe ratio compares the asset's realized excess return to its -Select- over a...

  • Agree or Disagree and Why? Question: overview of financial instruments including but not limited to stocks,...

    Agree or Disagree and Why? Question: overview of financial instruments including but not limited to stocks, bonds, and derivative securities – i.e., securities that “derive” their value from other securities (examples include options, futures, swaps, etc.). Emphasis is also placed on the securities markets. How the bond market works. The bond market is where investors go to trade (buy and sell) debt securities, prominently bonds, which may be issued by corporations or governments. It is also known as the debt...

  • 10. The DuPont equation Corporate decision makers and analysts often use a technique called DuPont analysis...

    10. The DuPont equation Corporate decision makers and analysts often use a technique called DuPont analysis to understand and assess the factors that drive a company’s financial performance, as measured by its return on equity (ROE). Depending on the version used, the DuPont equation will deconstruct the firm’s ROE, its best measure of financial performance, into two or three important factors, or drivers. DuPont analysis can be conducted using either the traditional DuPont equation or the extended DuPont equation. The...

  • 10. The DuPont equation Aa Aa E Corporate decision makers and analysts often use a technique...

    10. The DuPont equation Aa Aa E Corporate decision makers and analysts often use a technique called DuPont analysis to understand and assess the factors that drive a company's financial performance, as measured by its return on equity (ROE). Depending on the version used, the DuPont equation will deconstruct the firm's ROE, its best measure of financial performance, into two or three important factors, or drivers. DuPont analysis can be conducted using either the traditional DuPont equation or the extended...

  • DuPONT ANALYSIS A firm has been experiencing low profitability in recent years. Perform an analysis of...

    DuPONT ANALYSIS A firm has been experiencing low profitability in recent years. Perform an analysis of the firm's financial position using the DuPont equation. The firm has no lease payments but has a $2 million sinking fund payment on its debt. The most recent industry average ratios and the firm's financial statements are as follows: Industry Average Ratios Current ratio 3.34x Fixed assets turnover 7.44x Debt-to-capital ratio 19.28% Total assets turnover 3.70x Times interest earned 35.45x Profit margin 12.64% EBITDA...

  • Using the information provided below. Calculate the Marketing Return on Sales (ROS) for Apple. (7.5 pts)  Marketing...

    Using the information provided below. Calculate the Marketing Return on Sales (ROS) for Apple. (7.5 pts)  Marketing Return on Sales = Net Marketing Contribution / Net Sales Calculate the ROS for Microsoft. (7.5 pts) Which company has the better ROS? (5 pts) What does the ROS tell us about the marketing efforts. (5 pts) In 2014, Apple reported profits of more than $50 billion on sales of $182 billion. For that same period, Microsoft posted a profit of almost $30 billion...

  • first two photos are the background information for the questions. There are requirements in the third...

    first two photos are the background information for the questions. There are requirements in the third image. QUESTION THREE Red Tree Limited (Red). Blue Tree Limited (Blue), and Green Tree Limited (Green) are three independent companies owned by three different groups of shareholders in the City of Lightbridge. Red owns 5 parcels of land north of Avenue X. The parcels are of equal size in square blocks measuring 25 square kilometres each. Blue owns another 5 parcels of land, all...

ADVERTISEMENT
Free Homework Help App
Download From Google Play
Scan Your Homework
to Get Instant Free Answers
Need Online Homework Help?
Ask a Question
Get Answers For Free
Most questions answered within 3 hours.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT