Describe the origins of claims of hospitals cost shifting?
Describe conditions under which hospital cost shifting can occur and its causality?
Describe price discrimination and its application to hospitals?
The definition, existence, and extent of hospital “cost shifting” are points of debate among participants and stakeholders in discussions of health care policy and reform. The academic literature defines the term precisely and characterizes the range of its effect. Even though that literature has grown considerably in recent years, not since the mid-1990s has it been systematically reviewed and summarized (Morrisey 1993, 1994, 1996; see also Coulam and Gaumer 1991). In this article, I update those older reviews, summarize the relevant features of and changes to health care policy, and place the results in today's policy context.
That hospitals charge different payers (health plans and government programs) different amounts for the same service even at the same time is a phenomenon well known to economists as price discrimination (Reinhardt 2006). That hospitals charge one payer more because it received less (relative to costs or trend) from another also is widely believed. This is a dynamic, causal process that I call cost shifting, following Morrisey (1993, 1994, 1996) and Ginsburg (2003), among others. Price discrimination and cost shifting are related but different notions. The first depends on differences in market power, the ability to profitably charge one payer more than another but with no causal connection between the two prices charged. The second has a direct connection between prices charged. In cost shifting, if one payer (Medicare, say) pays less relative to costs, another (a private insurer, say) will necessarily pay more. Whereas cost shifting implies price discrimination, price discrimination does not imply that cost shifting has occurred or, if it has, at what rate (i.e., how much one payer's price changed relative to that of another). Cost-shifting is either an economic situation where one individual, group, or government underpays for a service, resulting another individual, group or government overpaying for a service (shifting compared to expected burden).It can occur where one group pays a smaller share of costs than before, resulting in another group paying a larger share of costs than before (shifting compared to previous arrangement). Some commentators on health policy in the United States elieve the former currently happens in medicare and Medicaid as they underpay for services resulting in private insures overpaying. In 1995, health affairsstarted a study testing the “cost-shifting” theory using a unique new data set that combines MarketScan private claims data with Medicare hospital cost reports, the study ran from 1995-2009. In May 2013 when the findings were released, the study found that a 10 percent reduction in Medicare payment rates led to an estimated reduction in private payment rates of 3 percent or 8 percent, depending on the statistical model used. These payment rate spillovers may reflect an effort by hospitals to rein in their operating costs in the face of lower Medicare payment rates.
A big decline in both auto accident and severe injury frequency has not produced a corresponding decline in loss costs. The slack has been taken up by inflated soft tissue injury claims fueled by hospital cost shift. Financially savvy hospital administrators and new software that “enhances” billing techniques have overcome claim deterrents so effectively that the industry seems unaware. There is an answer, but the industry may be satisfied with the status quo for now.
A 2008 report by the Insurance Research Council (IRC) provides
empirical evidence that since 2000, a significant decrease in auto
claim frequency has been mysteriously offset by an equally
significant rise in severity, leaving loss costs essentially
unchanged. Of particular note, the Insurance Research Council
report points to a study by the National Safety Institute showing
that improved automobile safety engineering has been lowering the
frequency of serious injuries and deaths. This makes the rise in
bodily injury and personal injury protection claim severity
particularly vexing.It might be argued that because hospitals
initially bill all of their patients at their chargemaster prices,
they do not engage in "price discrimination"—the practice of
charging different customers different prices for identical goods
or services. Invoices at chargemaster prices, however, are
insincere, in the sense that they would yield truly enormous
profits if those prices were actually paid. The reality is that
hospitals accept different payments from different payers for
identical services, and that can properly be called price
discrimination.
Could a public healthcare system use price discrimination—paying
medical service providers different fees, depending on the service
provider's quality—lead to improvements in social welfare? We show
that differentiating medical fees by quality increases social
welfare relative to uniform pricing (i.e. quality‐invariant fee
schedules) whenever hospitals and doctors have private information
about their own ability. We also show that by moving from uniform
to differentiated medical fees, the public healthcare system can
effectively incentivise good doctors and hospitals (i.e.
low‐cost‐types) to provide even higher levels of quality than they
would under complete information. In the socially optimal
quality‐differentiated medical fee system, low‐cost‐type
medical‐service providers enjoy a rent due to their informational
advantage. Informational rent is socially beneficial because it
gives service providers a strong incentive to invest in the extra
training required to deliver high‐quality services at low cost,
providing yet another efficiency gain from quality‐differentiated
medical fees.
Describe the origins of claims of hospitals cost shifting? Describe conditions under which hospital cost shifting...
What is fermentation? Under what conditions does it occur? What is its purpose? Describe the major differences between anaerobic and aerobic respiration in terms of reactions, products, and energy yield. Yeast is capable of both aerobic and anaerobic respiration, but frequently performs anaerobic respiration regardless of the oxygen content of its environment. What advantage might this provide the yeast?
Describe the conditions under which quarantine might be expected to affect the virulence of a pathogen. What are some key ethical issues that you see as possibly arising from the imposition of quarantine?
[3 marks] Describe conditions under which an implementation of Quicksort would be slower than a good implementation of Merge Sort. (The conditions could involve properties of the implementation, or properties of the inputs, or both.) Justify your answer.
as future hospital administrators, are the winners: hospitals, physicians, insurers and payers or patients? Are some form of regulation required to keep the market competitive? Do these trends go against the historical roots of US medicine? And if they do, how might they affect the current hospital governance structure? Are members of the medical staff truly independent if they are employees? Reading that goes along with the question above......... Hospital acquisition trends continue to persist, according to a report from...
PLEASE HELP WITH OPTICS! Need a long explanation. 4. Describe the conditions under which each type of lens will form a virtual image. THANK YOU SO MUCH WILL RATE 5-STARS!
Explain under which conditions an increase in the dividend payment can be interpreted as a signal of: a. Good news. b. Bad news. a. Good news. Under which conditions can an increase in the dividend payment be interpreted as a signal of good news: (Select the best choice below.) A. By increasing dividends managers signal that they believe that future earnings will be high enough to maintain the new dividend payment. B. Raising dividends gives investors more cash, so the...
Problem 1 Suppose you the owner of a hospital that treats patients in a particular city and that you are the only available hospital around. Your cost structure is such that the marginal cost of treating an extra patient is equal to MC(q)= (1/2) q What is the price you would charge if you only treated privately insured patients that have the following demand curve: P(q) = 150 – q Problem 2 Now suppose that 100 elderly people moved into...
6. Price discrimination and welfare Barefeet is a monopolist that produces Ooh boots, an amazingly trendy brand with no close substitutes. The following graph shows the market demand and marginal revenue curves Barefeet faces, as well as its marginal cost curve, which is constant at $40 per pair of Ooh boots. For simplicity, assume that fixed costs are equal to zero; this, combined with the fact that the firm's marginal cost (MC) is constant, means that its marginal cost curve is...
Background or Scenario: Sisters Charity Hospital (SCH) is located in a diverse and highly-populated area. The patients are disproportionately lower-income, many eligible for state public aid and Medicaid healthcare insurance. In addition to this population, the hospital serves a high number of poor and elderly patients, many of whom are covered under the Medicare program, and some of those who also have Medicaid insurance, being dually eligible for both government health insurance programs. SCH is a tax-exempt, charitable organization formed...
In plain language, describe what the oxygen-hemoglobin dissociation curve shows. Under normal conditions, the curve can shift to the right and left. A right shift can be induced by increased temperature and lower pH among other things. Describe what a right shift means in terms of hemoglobin’s relationship to oxygen. In your answer, be sure you address what is actually happening at the level of the protein (hemoglobin is a protein). Discuss what types of molecular interactions that can cause...