Is there a dummy variable trap come to Logistic Regression? For example, if there are 3 categories in a feature, should there be 3 dummy variables or 2 when it comes to logistic regression.
Understanding Dummy Variable Traps In Regression
Using categorical data in Multiple Regression Models is a powerful method to include non-numeric data types into a regression model. Categorical data refers to data values which represent categories - data values with a fixed and unordered number of values, for instance gender (male/female) or season (summer/winder/spring/fall). In a regression model, these values can be represented by dummy variables - variables containing values such as 1 or 0 representing the presence or absence of the categorical value.
By including dummy variable in a regression model however, one should be careful of the Dummy Variable Trap. The Dummy Variable trap is a scenario in which the independent variables are multicollinear - a scenario in which two or more variables are highly correlated; in simple terms one variable can be predicted from the others.
To demonstrate the Dummy Variable Trap, take the case of gender (male/female) as an example. Including a dummy variable for each is redundant (of male is 0, female is 1, and vice-versa), however doing so will result in the following linear model:
y ~ b + {0|1} male + {0|1} female
Represented in matrix form:
| y1 | | y2 | Y = | y3 | |... | | yn |
| 1 m1 F1 | | 1 m2 f2 | X = | 1 m3 f3 | |... ... ... | | 1 mn fn |
In the above model, the sum of all category dummy variable for each row is equal to the intercept value of that row - in other words there is perfect multi-collinearity (one value can be predicted from the other values). Intuitively, there is a duplicate category: if we dropped the male category it is inherently defined in the female category (zero female value indicate male, and vice-versa).
The solution to the dummy variable trap is to drop one of the categorical variables (or alternatively, drop the intercept constant) - if there are m number of categories, use m-1 in the model, the value left out can be thought of as the reference value and the fit values of the remaining categories represent the change from this reference.
As an example, lets take data containing 3 categories - C1, C2, and C3:
C1 | C2 | C3 | y |
1 | 0 | 0 | 12.4 |
1 | 0 | 0 | 11.9 |
0 | 1 | 0 | 8.3 |
0 | 1 | 0 | 3.1 |
0 | 0 | 1 | 5.4 |
0 | 0 | 1 | 6.2 |
Using R, we can fit this model in several ways, but for demonstration I'll use the ordinary least squares linear algebra equation:
B = (XTX)-1XTY
The matrix cannot be inverted because it is singular. To fix the issue, we can remove the intercept, or alternatively remove one of the dummy variable columns.
The calculated values are now referenced to the dropped dummy variable (in this case C1). In other words, if the category is C2 it is -3.95 less than the reference (in this example the reference value is 12.15).
In some cases it may be necessary to program dummy variables directly into a model. However in most cases a statistical package such as R can do the math for you - in R categories can be represented by factors, letting R deal with the details:
In short, when modelling a categorical variable with N possible values, you should use N−1 dummy variables.
When you know that the class is not A, B, or C, you know it must be D.
One might think that you would only need 2 dummy variables since that allows for 4 possible combinations. One would indicate whether it is in the sets [A,B] or [C,D], the other one would indicate whether it is in the sets [A,C] or [B,D]. However, that implies that A and B are somehow more related than A and D.
Is there a dummy variable trap come to Logistic Regression? For example, if there are 3...
We have explored the use of logistic regression for when the dependent variable has two classes, Yes or No, Admit or Not, etc. Suppose that there are m (>2) classes. For example, Buy, Sell, or Hold. How will you model this using logistic regression? You don't have to solve it, but provide a strategy to model this.
3. A researcher collected data to study the effect of smoking on the risk of a heart attack. The variables were x - a categorical variable with the categories: (1) Present smoker (2) Past smoker (smoked but quit) (3) Non-smoker Y - a binary variable defined by: Y 1 if the person had a heart attack Y-0 if the person didn't have a heart attack Since the X-variables are categorical, the researcher coded the X-variable by two dummy variables: X2...
Logistic regression is used when you want to? a. Predict a continuous variable from dichotomous ones. b. Predict a dichotomous variable from continuous or dichotomous variables. c. Predict any categorical variable from other categorical variables. d. Predict a continuous variable from dichotomous or continuous variables.
9.) What characteristic of the outcome variable (Y) suggests that a logistic regression is a suitable methodology? a.) When the outcome is a continuous variable b.) When the outcome variable has a large variance c.) When the outcome is always positive d.) When the outcome is a dichotomous variable 10.) If, in a multiple regression of the price of a diamond against the two predictor variables, weight and color, the R2 of the regression was 0.985, then which of the...
Suppose X, is a numerical variable and X, is a dummy variable with two categories and the regression equation for a sample of n 27 is Y-4-6X..3 a. Interpret the regression coefficient associated with variable b. Interpret the regression coefficient associated with variable c. Suppose that the ISTAT test statistic for testing the contribution of vanable Xis 249. At the 0.01 level of significance, is there evidence that vanable makes a significant contribution to the model?
Explain in full how you will use a dummy variable regression to test for a structural break. Also discuss the advantages of using a dummy variable regression over the Chow test when testing for structural break in data.
For logistic regression (later). y is a value between 0 and 1 Come up with a function of y that stretches it onto the real line. That is y E [O,1] f(y) E [- co , co] Come up with a function f.
Use the Eli Orchid data to extend your regression model in P2 with the dummy variable representing the weekend. 1. In column B calculate the values of the dummy variable representing weekend (w). The dummy variable w is set to 1 for Saturday or Sunday. Otherwise it is set to 0. DO NOT type the values in - you must build a formula.2. Run the regression multiple analysis. Generate the regression output in a yellow cell below. 3. Use the...
4 & 5 QUESTION 4 What is a major difference between linear regression and logistic regression? a. The nature of the independent variable(s) b. The nature of the dependent variable c. The number of independent variables d. The number of dependent variables QUESTION 5 Which one of the following statistical tests would the researcher hope to have a non-significant result (p > .05) in a logistic regression analysis? a. The likelihood ratio test b. The logit step test C. The...
Dummy Variable Regression: Choose any metric variable as the dependent variable (you can use the same one that you used in Part A) and choose gender as an independent variable. Also choose one more metric variable as an additional independent variable. Once again, however, you must sort through the metric independent variables until you find one that, along with gender, produces a significant F-calc. Use alpha = .05 here as well. You only need to report the model that produced...