Volkswagen's Hedging Strategy
1. Why did Volkswagen suffer a 95% drop in its 4th quarter, 2003 profits?
2. Do you think the Volkswagen’s decision to hedge only 30% of its anticipated U.S. sales was a good? Why or why not?
3. Do you think the Volkswagen’s decision to revert back to hedging 70% of its foreign currency exposure was a good decision? Why or why not?
Embraer and the Wild Ride of the Brazilian Real
4. Is a decline in value of the real against the U.S. dollar good or bad for Embraer? Why?
5. How can Embraer reduce these risks?
6. Do you think Embraer's decision to hedge against further appreciation of the real in the early 2000s was a good decision? Why or why not?
7. Since 2008 Embraer has significantly reduced its dollar hedging operations. Is this wise? Why or why not?
Subaru's Sales Boom Thanks to the Weaker Yen
8. Why has Subaru concentrated its manufacturing in Japan?
9. What was the impact of the depreciation of the yen on Subaru’s profits since 2012?
10. Why is Subaru increasing its US production? Do you think it is a good decision? Why or why not?
All 3 articles
11. What did you learn from these stories about hedging foreign exchange rate risk?
Answer:
1) Volkswagen, Europe's largest carmaker, reported a 95 percent drop in 2003 fourth-quarter profits, which slumped from €1.05 billion to a mere €50 million. For all of 2003, Volkswagen's operating profit fell by 50 percent from the record levels attained in 2002. Although the profit slump had multiple causes, two factors were the focus of much attention—the sharp rise in the value of the euro against the dollar during 2003 and Volkswagen's decision to hedge only 30 percent of its foreign currency exposure, as opposed to the 70 percent it had traditionally hedged. In total, currency losses due to the dollar's rise are estimated to have reduced Volkswagen's operating profits by some €1.2 billion ($1.5 billion).
2) The rise in the value of the euro during 2003 took many companies by surprise. Since its introduction January 1, 1999, when it became the currency unit of 12 members of the European Union, the euro had recorded a volatile trading history against the U.S. dollar. In early 1999, the exchange rate stood at €1 = $1.17, but by October 2000 it had slumped to €1 = $0.83. Although it recovered, reaching parity of €1 = $1.00 in late 2002, few analysts predicted a rapid rise in the value of the euro against the dollar during 2003. As so often happens in the foreign exchange markets, the experts were wrong; by late 2003, the exchange rate stood at €1 = $1.25. For Volkswagen, which made cars in Germany and exported them to the United States, the fall in the value of the dollar against the euro during 2003 was devastating. To understand what happened, consider a Volkswagen Jetta built in Germany for export to the United States.
3) Volkswagen could have insured against this adverse movement in exchange rates by entering the foreign exchange market in late 2002 and buying a forward contract for dollars at an exchange rate of around $1 = €1 (a forward contract gives the holder the right to exchange one currency for another at some point in the future at a predetermined exchange rate). Called hedging, the financial strategy of buying forward guarantees that at some future point, such as 180 days, Volkswagen would have been able to exchange the dollars it got from selling Jettas in the United States into euros at $1 = €1, irrespective of what the actual exchange rate was at that time. In 2003, such a strategy would have been good for Volkswagen. However, hedging is not without its costs. For one thing, if the euro had declined in value against the dollar, instead of appreciating as it did, Volkswagen would have made even more profit per car in euros by not hedging (a dollar at the end of 2003 would have bought more euros than a dollar at the end of 2002). For another thing, hedging is expensive because foreign exchange dealers will charge a high commission for selling currency forward. Volkswagen decided to hedge just 30 percent of its anticipated U.S. sales in 2003 through forward contracts, rather than the 70 percent it had historically hedged. The decision cost the company more than €1 billion. For 2004, the company reverted back to hedging 70 percent of its foreign currency exposure.
*AS per the HomeworkLib policy give you answer, for other, post separately, thank you & rate.
Volkswagen's Hedging Strategy 1. Why did Volkswagen suffer a 95% drop in its 4th quarter, 2003 pr...
1. Why do you think that the Chinese historically pegged the value of the yuan to the U.S. dollar? 2. Why did the Chinese move to a managed-float system in 2005? 3. What are the benefits that China might gain by allowing the yuan to float freely against other major currencies such as the U.S. dollar and the euro? What are the risks? What do you think they should do? 4. Is there any evidence that the Chinese kept the...
The Coffee Buzz: The Impact of Exchange Rates on Coffee You are about to read a short case detailing a situation in the global coffee market. Together, Brazil and Vietnam produce more than two-thirds of the world’s coffee. However, while Brazil is enjoying the benefit of strong revenues from its exports, Vietnam, thanks to the impact of exchange rates, is not. You will be asked to answer questions linking your knowledge from the chapter to the situation detailed in the...
Case assignments must be completed with a written 2-page study on the assigned case questions in the textbook. The format requested for these assignments is based on elaborating and including two basic parts in the essay: 1) in a bullet presentation style (one phrase each bullet), list a summary of the key issues, situations, problems, opportunities and threats you may identify as relevant; 2) answer all the questions listed in each case in two or three sound paragraphs. Use the...
DQuestion 36 2 pts The following table shows the number of U.S. dollars required to buy one British pound and the number of U.S. dollars required to buy one euro between February 1, 2016, and September 1, 2016: U.S. Dollars Required U.S. Dollars to Buy 1 British Pound 1.429 Required to Buy 1 Euro 1.1092 Date February 1, 2016 March 1, 2016 1.425 April 1, 2016 1.432 May 1, 20161.452 June 1, 2016 1.420 July 1, 20161.313 August 1, 2016...
1. John sold a call option on Euro for $.04 per unit. The strike price was $1.30, and the spot rate at the time the option was exercised was $1.32. Assume John bought the Euro from the market if the option was exercised. Also assume that there are 100,000 units in a Euro option. What was John’s net profit on the call option? Baylor Bank believes the New Zealand dollar will appreciate over the next 20 days from $.50 to...
Module 9 – Foreign Exchange Rate Risk Homework Exercise Part 1 1. Suppose that the EUR:USD is trading at 1.3342; the GBP:JPY is trading at 67.7600; and the EUR:GBP is trading at 0.8165. What should the USD:JPY rate be? 2. If a price index for US goods stands at 118.93 and the same price index for European goods (i.e., computed from the same consumption basket) stands at 183.34; what is the fair (under the theory of PPP) spot exchange rate...
2006, interest rates increased from 5% to 7%, when this happens consumers are A. less likely to save, that is, sell a financial asset. B. more likely to save, that is, sell a financial asset. C. less likely to save, that is, purchase a financial asset. D. more likely to save, that is, purchase a financial asset. I. In 2. If commercial banks hold all their assets in the form of required reserves: A. only they will be able to...
How did Samsung overtake Panasonic and Philips? What core competencies (resources and capabilities) did the firm possess that helped it to be successful? (Discuss the international strategy that Samsung executed.) Samsung Leadership Era: 2000–Present Samsung group was founded in 1938 by Byung-Chull Lee as a simple trading company in Taegu, Korea that exported basic goods such as dried fish, vegetables, and fruit before expanding into several business lines, including insurance, securities, and retail.43 In 1969, Lee decided to enter the...
Please provide a summary of this case and answer ALL posted questions. Thank you so very much in advance! closing case The Decline of Zimbabwe wew the lowest econom 2000. Between 1999 and 2009 I 1980. the southern Ac e of imbabwe gained independence growth rate ever recorded with an ecline of 6.1 percent in from colonial master, Great Britain. Speaking of the time, the late The decline occurred after Mugabe launched a "fast-track and room Tanzania President, Julius Nyerere,...
CASE 1-5 Financial Statement Ratio Computation Refer to Campbell Soup Company's financial Campbell Soup statements in Appendix A. Required: Compute the following ratios for Year 11. Liquidity ratios: Asset utilization ratios:* a. Current ratio n. Cash turnover b. Acid-test ratio 0. Accounts receivable turnover c. Days to sell inventory p. Inventory turnover d. Collection period 4. Working capital turnover Capital structure and solvency ratios: 1. Fixed assets turnover e. Total debt to total equity s. Total assets turnover f. Long-term...