Question

Scenario:  Kendahl Plastics Corporation contracts with NASA to manufacture component parts used in communications satellites. NASA reimburses Kendahl on the basis of the actual manufacturing costs it incurs, plus a fixed percentage. Prior to being awarded a contract, Kendahl must submit a bid that details the estimated costs associated with each project. An examination of Kendahl’s job cost sheets reveals that actual costs consistently exceed cost estimates quoted during the bidding process. As a consequence, NASA ends up paying considerably more than the bids Kendahl submits.

A Kendahl representative was recently quoted as saying, “We really aren’t overcharging NASA for the work that we do. The actual costs shown on our job cost sheets seem high only because we are forced to understate our bid estimates in order to be awarded contracts. It’s a common practice, and everybody does it. The truth of the matter is companies that quote realistic bid prices are not awarded contracts.”

Let us assume that it is common practice to purposely underestimate bids in order to win NASA contracts:

(MUST POST FIRST) Initial Post – As an employee, write an internal memo to your manager addressing the following:

• Is it wrong for Kendahl to take part in this activity as long as it does not overstate the actual costs it incurs?
• If you were part of Kendahl, would you have personally have issues using this bidding practice?
• Research and cite common ethical bidding practices. What other bidding practices have your read about that you would be ok with using, even though they may be unethical or push the boundaries of being ethical.

Answer 1

It is not o71ong to take PaticfPaton n the bid to wnn NASA ComYact However, Tt s cnfair and unethical o ovostale e celual cststhad kandah ncas Actualy,-the ehole tndusy ts folomg an unet cal Pactice. e equletoy hody Shuld nvene mto s matlen amd stop tis Pa elice. Thenefone, 9at Re kandalt tdce Pant ne bid and choolges e Coplect Prices w.cut ovestatg them. . cmethtcal biddig has become one of the biggest chalege afthe rdeety eadys. kehdahl plastics conponaton has also Promoted the Samme b quong canderstaded Yate to gatn anedge ova he Competitors and leten ovadhar g NASA. The bid should be given closet to he aelual tigune. Eteen e company should dete he aelual espense -for tshotuld abstan Prom such Practies (). Betg of Prt of te leehdohl groue Pooraly ts Practice wld be condoned. Tf his unfoar means

s betng adopled kehdahl shaald forcacond PYoo.fs of such biadtng to NASA md then Present them -e actual Coststat 9t ooald hove to incon. NASA Cutd adopt some othen costfng metod co lustve bldings ebe complemenbay biddng. d Rotedion, Bid supPiession, (3). Common bidding Proctices con be: developing tmPn1al specifications he not beng foujed on one Raoticula Condactos on Prodc speciftation. By devcloping objectve Supplion selection calenia ke not ust focustng Costs a the maim divo On the Experience ete.emctioral uson nta face etc. as hen dtvou to select the ftral Conlnon R Oping ontne biddtng9 cohere the name and specefi cations ane not disclosed wre lcept anonymo and and Just eY bids ane disclosed not allotinghe nelated Panties of the conan asleng bids to take Pot n em,