Question

Question: What other information would you need to help you to analyze the ethical dilemmas in...

Question: What other information would you need to help you to analyze the ethical dilemmas in the fact pattern below.

Fact pattern: Barbara and Yvette are partners. At the start of their relationship, they agreed to marry only when all same-sex couples in every jurisdiction could do the same. Just last month, the couple finally and excitedly began to plan their wedding. Barbara and Yvette periodically discussed death over the course of their 15-year relationship. Both expressed a strong opposition to “being kept alive by artificial measures in the face of medical futility.” For Barbara, her quality of life hinges on her ability to talk and write music; for Yvette, it is her ability to dance and walk. Barbara and Yvette get into a terrible car accident. Other than some minor cuts and bruises, Barbara walks away unscathed. Yvette—the driver—is comatose and incapacitated. The doctors believe Yvette will come out of her coma; however, they suspect she may suffer long-term cognitive deficits due to cerebral hypoxia. They are also uncertain if she will regain the use of her legs. Yvette’s only family is her sister, Melody. While the two are friendly, they have never been particularly close. After the accident, Barbara calls Melody. Melody arrives at the hospital and demands that the medical team keep Yvette on the ventilator. Melody argues that Yvette not only has a valid medical care directive, but that Yvette designated Melody her health care proxy, not Barbara. Melody also claims that while Yvette may have told Barbara something else, Yvette’s medical care directive states that in the event of serious illness or injury, Yvette wanted all aggressive therapies and life-sustaining measures to be completely exhausted before “pulling the plug.” After 48 hours of searching and inquiring with Yvette’s lawyer, friends, distant family, primary care doctor, other health care providers and bank, Yvette’s medical care directive and other documentation are nowhere to be found. Barbara and Melody cannot reach an agreement as to what “Yvette would have wanted.” Yvette’s physicians are reluctant to remove the ventilator. Not only are the doctors troubled by the Barbara and Melody’s divergent beliefs about Yvette’s end-of-life care wishes, they remain unsure about Yvette’s prognosis

0 0
Add a comment Improve this question Transcribed image text
Answer #1

Other information needed to analyze the ethical dilemmas in the fact pattern given in the question are:

  • The relationship between Yvette and Barbara, whether they had any issues in their relationship or not.
  • If Barbara had any ulterior motives when Yvette's ventilator support is taken off and she dies.
  • Whether or not Barbara will inherit Yvette's assets.
  • The testimony of one of their common friends regarding Barbara's statement.
  • Their financial status to continue the treatment.
  • The success and failure rate of Yvette's treatment.
Add a comment
Know the answer?
Add Answer to:
Question: What other information would you need to help you to analyze the ethical dilemmas in...
Your Answer:

Post as a guest

Your Name:

What's your source?

Earn Coins

Coins can be redeemed for fabulous gifts.

Not the answer you're looking for? Ask your own homework help question. Our experts will answer your question WITHIN MINUTES for Free.
Similar Homework Help Questions
  • Question: What are the bioethical dilemmas in the fact pattern below? Fact Pattern Barbara and Yvette...

    Question: What are the bioethical dilemmas in the fact pattern below? Fact Pattern Barbara and Yvette are partners. At the start of their relationship, they agreed to marry only when all same-sex couples in every jurisdiction could do the same. Just last month, the couple finally and excitedly began to plan their wedding. Barbara and Yvette periodically discussed death over the course of their 15-year relationship. Both expressed a strong opposition to “being kept alive by artificial measures in the...

  • question: How should this case be resolved? What resolution(s) do you suggest, and why? fact pattern:...

    question: How should this case be resolved? What resolution(s) do you suggest, and why? fact pattern: Barbara and Yvette are partners. At the start of their relationship, they agreed to marry only when all same-sex couples in every jurisdiction could do the same. Just last month, the couple finally and excitedly began to plan their wedding. Barbara and Yvette periodically discussed death over the course of their 15-year relationship. Both expressed a strong opposition to “being kept alive by artificial...

  • Twenty-nine year old Janet and her husband Jack were driving home from her ob-gyn appointment when...

    Twenty-nine year old Janet and her husband Jack were driving home from her ob-gyn appointment when tragedy struck. Another driver, elderly and distracted by an incoming text message, ran a red light and T-boned Janet and Jack’s Mini-Cooper. Both young people sustained severe injuries. Jack died enroute to the hospital. Janet survives, having escaped injury except to her head; but that was unfortunately massive. Her physicians now say, a month after the accident, that the prognosis is grim. The best...

  • the sheer speed with which end-stage liver failure can consume a patient is what makes the...

    the sheer speed with which end-stage liver failure can consume a patient is what makes the disease so devastating.1,2 Unfortunately, Ms. S.’s family had never been informed about that reality. When they brought her in for a mere urinary tract infection, they were shocked that it took only days for her heart, lungs, and immune system to fail alongside her liver. Her family waited in hopeful anticipation for Ms. S.’s condition to take a turn for the better, and therefore...

  • the sheer speed with which end-stage liver failure can consume a patient is what makes the...

    the sheer speed with which end-stage liver failure can consume a patient is what makes the disease so devastating.1,2 Unfortunately, Ms. S.’s family had never been informed about that reality. When they brought her in for a mere urinary tract infection, they were shocked that it took only days for her heart, lungs, and immune system to fail alongside her liver. Her family waited in hopeful anticipation for Ms. S.’s condition to take a turn for the better, and therefore...

  • Then sheer speed with which end-stage liver failure can consume a patient is what makes the...

    Then sheer speed with which end-stage liver failure can consume a patient is what makes the disease so devastating.1,2 Unfortunately, Ms. S.’s family had never been informed about that reality. When they brought her in for a mere urinary tract infection, they were shocked that it took only days for her heart, lungs, and immune system to fail alongside her liver. Her family waited in hopeful anticipation for Ms. S.’s condition to take a turn for the better, and therefore...

  • sheer speed with which end-stage liver failure can consume a patient is what makes the disease...

    sheer speed with which end-stage liver failure can consume a patient is what makes the disease so devastating.1,2 Unfortunately, Ms. S.’s family had never been informed about that reality. When they brought her in for a mere urinary tract infection, they were shocked that it took only days for her heart, lungs, and immune system to fail alongside her liver. Her family waited in hopeful anticipation for Ms. S.’s condition to take a turn for the better, and therefore repeatedly...

  • The sheer speed with which end-stage liver failure can consume a patient is what makes the disease so devastating.1,2 Un...

    The sheer speed with which end-stage liver failure can consume a patient is what makes the disease so devastating.1,2 Unfortunately, Ms. S.’s family had never been informed about that reality. When they brought her in for a mere urinary tract infection, they were shocked that it took only days for her heart, lungs, and immune system to fail alongside her liver. Her family waited in hopeful anticipation for Ms. S.’s condition to take a turn for the better, and therefore...

  • Ethically, health-care providers should refuse all patients that do not have the ability to pay. refuse...

    Ethically, health-care providers should refuse all patients that do not have the ability to pay. refuse patients when the practice is already oversubscribed. only refuse patients when the provider has announced his or her retirement. refer all low-income patients to a charitable organization instead of providing any health care to these patients. It is never acceptable to withhold information from patients for fear they will refuse treatment. True False Knowledge that, if revealed, would harm not only the client but...

  • What advice would you provide to Kathleen with regard to the CMO and Linda? Make sure...

    What advice would you provide to Kathleen with regard to the CMO and Linda? Make sure you support your position(s). From the onset, what would you recommend Kathleen do differently the next time she is faced with a similar situation? Tools* Download Human Resources in Healthcare Managing for Success Experiential Exercises Sexual Orientation Discrimination have been difficult because the health center Case was located in a rural county in Mississippi Note: This case was written by Brian Cooper: Kathleen was...

ADVERTISEMENT
Free Homework Help App
Download From Google Play
Scan Your Homework
to Get Instant Free Answers
Need Online Homework Help?
Ask a Question
Get Answers For Free
Most questions answered within 3 hours.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT