Question

Imagine there is a God who knows the future free action of human beings. If God...

Imagine there is a God who knows the future free action of human beings. If God does know you will freely do some act X, then it is true that you will indeed do X. But if you are free, would you not be free to avoid doing X? Given that it is foreknown you will do X, it appears you would not be free to refrain from the act.

0 0
Add a comment Improve this question Transcribed image text
Answer #1

Answer

You will not be free to refrain from the act as it is already foreknown that you will do X. If the God knows about your free action, then the God knows that you will freely do something and also that you could have refrained. This act being foreknown to God does not make it necessary. If God does know you will freely do some act X, then some residual sense in which your freely doing X is something that cannot be altered.

Add a comment
Know the answer?
Add Answer to:
Imagine there is a God who knows the future free action of human beings. If God...
Your Answer:

Post as a guest

Your Name:

What's your source?

Earn Coins

Coins can be redeemed for fabulous gifts.

Not the answer you're looking for? Ask your own homework help question. Our experts will answer your question WITHIN MINUTES for Free.
Similar Homework Help Questions
  • Problem: Who Is within D Degrees of Separation? Given a series of "knows" relationships such as "...

    Problem: Who Is within D Degrees of Separation? Given a series of "knows" relationships such as "Alice knows Bob", a degree D, and a person P, output the group of people that are within D degrees of separation of person P For example, given the input, which consists of a network of acquaintances followed by one or more queries of the form "degree person" such as Alice knows Bob Carol knows Dave Carol knows Bob Bob knows Eve Eve knows...

  • It is known that roughly 2/3 of all human beings have a dominant right foot or...

    It is known that roughly 2/3 of all human beings have a dominant right foot or eye. Is there also right-sided dominance in kissing behavior? An article reported that in a random sample of 118 Kissing couples, both people in 74 of the couples tended to lean more to the right than to the left. (Use 0.05.) (a) If 2/3 of all kissing couples exhibit this right-leaning behavior, what is the probability that the number in a sample of 118...

  • home / study / business / economics / economics questions and answers / personal struggles with...

    home / study / business / economics / economics questions and answers / personal struggles with one's own tendencies, desires, lusts, and self-interest have placed ... Your question has been answered Let us know if you got a helpful answer. Rate this answer Question: Personal struggles with one's own tendencies, desires, lusts, and self-interest have placed peopl... Personal struggles with one's own tendencies, desires, lusts, and self-interest have placed people in conflict with other people and their own communities farther...

  • Now imagine yourself listening intently to each of the clients quoted below. First use the “You feel . . . because . . ....

    Now imagine yourself listening intently to each of the clients quoted below. First use the “You feel . . . because . . .” formula; then use your own words. Try to make the second response sound as natural (as much like yourself) as possible. After you use your own words, check to see if you have both a “you feel” part and a “because” part in your response. Case 1. A 28-year-old woman is talking about her job with...

  • Passage A Not only are there cases in which torture is morally permissible, but sometimes it...

    Passage A Not only are there cases in which torture is morally permissible, but sometimes it may be morally required. Suppose the police had someone in custody whom you suspected of having information that could help stop a plan to unleash a weapon of mass destruction upon a metropolitan area. Nothing should be prohibited in the attempt to get the needed information—not even torture. After all, we expect the police to do whatever is within their power to save an...

  • Difficulties Attracting and Retaining Human Capital in the Nursing Profession Imagine a job that pays well...

    Difficulties Attracting and Retaining Human Capital in the Nursing Profession Imagine a job that pays well above national averages and provides many opportunities for continuing education, specialization, and career advancement. It allows you to be active every day and to make a real difference in others’ lives, along with the kind of scheduling flexibility some describe as “fantastic!”208 Would you sign up? Strong salaries, lifelong learning opportunities, three-day workweeks, and meaningful work are common facets of a nursing career. And...

  • Please help!! Cultural messages, simply, are what everyone in a group knows that outsiders do not...

    Please help!! Cultural messages, simply, are what everyone in a group knows that outsiders do not know. They are a series of lenses that shape our perceptions, interpretations, boundaries, and values. Users: Anyone involved in a cross-cultural conflict. This includes not only people from different countries, but also people from different gender, age, ethnic, religious, regional, even different professional groups. (One might speak of the engineering culture or the business culture, for example.) Description: Culture is an essential part of...

  • case study CASE STUDY Mrs. Brown, a 48-year-old woman, is living with a diagnosis of breast...

    case study CASE STUDY Mrs. Brown, a 48-year-old woman, is living with a diagnosis of breast cancer. She has just come into the oncology clinic for her third round of chemotherapy. When asked how she is doing. Mrs. Brown starts speaking about how tired she is and how she is feeling burdened with keeping secrets from her daughter. Mrs. Brown has not told her daughter about her cancer diagnosis because she is afraid of how her daughter might react. Mrs....

  • Cuban culture and american culture Cultural messages, simply, are what everyone in a group knows that...

    Cuban culture and american culture Cultural messages, simply, are what everyone in a group knows that outsiders do not know. They are a series of lenses that shape our perceptions, interpretations, boundaries, and values. Users: Anyone involved in a cross-cultural conflict. This includes not only people from different countries, but also people from different gender, age, ethnic, religious, regional, even different professional groups. (One might speak of the engineering culture or the business culture, for example.) Description: Culture is an...

  • Case Study: The Buck Stops Here Read the case study on page 384 of your Human...

    Case Study: The Buck Stops Here Read the case study on page 384 of your Human Resource Management in Health Care text. For your post, use content from the readings to answer the following question: How would you advise Mary to proceed to address the situation, while avoiding unintentional unlawful employment discrimination practices under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act?   Case Study: “The Buck Stops Here” Mary Johnson, a registered nurse, and the new manager of the clinical staff...

ADVERTISEMENT
Free Homework Help App
Download From Google Play
Scan Your Homework
to Get Instant Free Answers
Need Online Homework Help?
Ask a Question
Get Answers For Free
Most questions answered within 3 hours.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT