Question

According to Joseph Collins, why should doctors lie to their patients? Why does Roger Higgs disagree with Collins’ view? Which view do you think best serves the patient? Explain why.

Answer 1

To start, a couple of words on the idea of a lie ...

In the event that I say something that is false, it doesn't pursue that I�ve told a lie.� Intention is important.� Lying includes a plan to beguile. I tell a lie when I say something I know to be false with the purpose that you acknowledge what I say as true.���

Be that as it may, see we can likewise expect to swindle by withholding data or by saying nothing at all.� In these cases, what we do appears to add up to lying.�

Collins contends that specialists �must as often as possible withhold reality from their patients, which is equivalent to lying� and that specialists �should develop lying as a fine art.�

Collins refers to a few cases in which he can't help thinking that lying was the right activity.

One case includes a patient who experienced a genuine ailment of the spinal cord.� The patient was informed that he has an exceptional type of �rheumatism� which required extraordinary treatment.� Collins guarantees that �had he been informed that he had an infection which was then all around accepted to be dynamic, fear would have discouraged him so intensely that he would not have possessed the capacity to offer the protection from its infringement which has stood him in such great stead.�

Another case includes a man who, subsequent to committing a quarter century to painting, went into advertising.� Five years after the fact, when his business was nearly achievement, he moved toward becoming ill.� He had medical procedure, and was later told what the medical procedure had accomplished.� He was not told, in any case, what the medical procedure had neglected to achieve and that he was relied upon to kick the bucket soon.� Over the following year, his business flourished.� Over the most recent couple of long stretches of his life, he at last took in the idea of his illness.� According to Collins, the double dealing saved him long stretches of dread and enabled him to get his business all together so that, when he passed on and the business was sold, it would give some pay to his family.� �Had he been told the truth�, Collins says, �black gloom would have been tossed over the world in which he moved, and he would have gone ahead with relating ineffectiveness�.��

Collins likewise refers to a few cases in which coming clean demonstrated sad ...

One case includes a legal counselor who experienced kidney disease.� Collins at first did not reveal to him the idea of his problem.� But rather he told the legal counselor that he would recoup on the off chance that he profoundly changed his lifestyle for a time.� The legal advisor demanded being come clean, so Collins disclosed to him the full idea of his disease.� Collins says that in the wake of being come clean, �the light of life started to glint from the dread that my words incited, and inside two months it sputtered out and kicked the bucket. ...� Had I misled him ... he may be alive today.��

Higgs noticed that there is a general inclination among

numerous specialists (and human services laborers all the more by and large) that it is admissible to lie � that it is, indeed, an aspect of their responsibilities as specialists.

However, customary profound quality reveals to us that lying requires solid justification.�����

Higgs contends that specialists (and human services laborers all the more for the most part) don't have unique exclusion from coming clean � �they have no unlimited power to lie

Higgs supported that lying always is not bad .

According to me both the views are beneficial in different situations but Collins point of view is much more beneficial for patients . Because if your are telling truth to the patient about something which he cannot do any thing then that type of truth is of no use . Psychology plays a important role in this .As if there is positive environment around you u will tend to live for longers life and it's better to live stressless life . If u know the truth u might be depress