Question

Bouvia v. Superior Court Utilitarianism vs. Kantian Ethics (Deontology) The particular issues this case raises for the v...

Bouvia v. Superior Court

Utilitarianism vs. Kantian Ethics (Deontology)

The particular issues this case raises for the views you choose to discuss, what advantages and disadvantages each view has and

which view offers the preferable solution.

0 0
Add a comment Improve this question Transcribed image text
Answer #1

Utilitarianism vs. Kantian Ethics :-

Advantages and disadvantages :

Kantianism and utilitarianism have different ways for determining whether an act we do is right or wrong. According to Kant, we should look at our maxims, or intentions, of the particular action. Kantians believe “human life is valuable because humans are the bearers of rational life. In other words, humans are free rational beings capable of rational behavior and should not be used purely for the enjoyment or happiness of another. On the other hand, Utilitarians believe that we should do actions that produce the greatest amount of happiness. The problem with this, however, is that it could involve using people as mere means and may lead to the sacrifice of lives for the greater good. Christopher Bennett expands on this point by stating that Utiliarians justify punishing an innocent party “if it is necessary to bring about a sufficiently important good effect” . Additionally, promises, which are typically binding in our society, can be broken if it produces a greater good. This can be applied to any promise, including those made with loved ones. Utilitarianism sometimes involves the sacrifice of an individual’s happiness or life in order to promote the greatest amount of happiness and the least amount of misery.

It is easier to determine an action as morally right in Kantian ethics than in utilitarian ethics. When data is scarce, Kantian theory offers more precision than utilitarianism because one can generally determine if somebody is being used as a mere means, even if the impact on human happiness is ambiguous. Kantians “consider only the proposals for an action that occur to them and check that these proposals use no other as mere means” . Contrastingly, utilitarianism compares all available acts and sees which has the best effects. Although utilitarianism has a larger scope than Kantianism, it is a more timely process. The decision-making method of calculating all of the potential costs and benefits of an action is extremely time consuming and leaves little time for promoting happiness, which is the Utilitarian’s goal.

Add a comment
Know the answer?
Add Answer to:
Bouvia v. Superior Court Utilitarianism vs. Kantian Ethics (Deontology) The particular issues this case raises for the v...
Your Answer:

Post as a guest

Your Name:

What's your source?

Earn Coins

Coins can be redeemed for fabulous gifts.

Not the answer you're looking for? Ask your own homework help question. Our experts will answer your question WITHIN MINUTES for Free.
Similar Homework Help Questions
  • select one theory of ethics to apply to the case study ("Evaluating a Case Study: Developing...

    select one theory of ethics to apply to the case study ("Evaluating a Case Study: Developing a Practical Ethical Viewpoint"). Based on your selected ethical theory, what are the main ethical concerns? Utilitarianism Deontology Ethical Intuitionism Virtue Ethics Ethical Non-Cognitivism Ethical Contractarianism Describe how each ethical theory might approach this situation. Which one is most consonant to your own worldview, and why? Case Study: You are on the executive committee of the XYZ organization of health care professionals. Each year...

  • Arrange View Share Window Help 7 Ethics Case Study Paper-Edited 125% v T View Zoom Insert...

    Arrange View Share Window Help 7 Ethics Case Study Paper-Edited 125% v T View Zoom Insert Table Chart Text Shape Media Comment Collaborat 2 Ethics Case Study Analyze the following case studies and respond to the questions attached in a short (3-5 page) paper. Post the answers as a Word document via Turnitin by the date indicated on the joule site. Consult the School of Nursing rubric for written assignments found on the joule site for the course. Ethics Case...

  • Review the following court case: Jackson v. Metropolitan Edison Co. 419 U.S. 345(1974) 1. What are...

    Review the following court case: Jackson v. Metropolitan Edison Co. 419 U.S. 345(1974) 1. What are the facts of this case? What is the issue? 2. In what court was it decided, and how did it get to that court? 3. What did the court below decide, and why? What did this court decide, and why? 4. What does it mean to be "affected with the public interest"? 5. What is the significance of the Fourteenth Amendment to the U.S....

  • a] Read the New York Times article, “In Narrow Decision, Supreme Court Sides With Baker Who...

    a] Read the New York Times article, “In Narrow Decision, Supreme Court Sides With Baker Who Turned Away Couple” . Briefly summarize the case. b] Use as many specific concepts and contents from this course to develop your argument either in favor or against that Supreme Court ruling. c] Can you identify any direct and/or indirect violence associated with this conflict? Article: WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court on Monday ruled in favor of a Colorado baker who had refused to...

  • Case 10.4 Gena Duckworth v. St. Louis Metropolitan Police Department 2007 U.S. App. LEXIS 17137 (8th...

    Case 10.4 Gena Duckworth v. St. Louis Metropolitan Police Department 2007 U.S. App. LEXIS 17137 (8th Cir.) The issue in the case that follows is whether assigning female police officers to the nightwatch is a bona fide occupational qualification. BENTON, CIRCUIT JUDGE. Three female officers sued their superiors for gender discrimination under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and the Missouri Human Rights Act. The district court denied the defense of qualified immunity to the police superiors....

  • TRUE/FALSE ___1. A reference to “RCW 4.12.020" means that a statute can be found on page...

    TRUE/FALSE ___1. A reference to “RCW 4.12.020" means that a statute can be found on page 12 of volume 4 of the Revised Code of Washington, part 20. ___2. The United States Congress has adopted one particular approach to ethics, and made it a part of the United States Code; all United States businesses must follow only those statutes in the United States Code, and are not allowed to determine what their businesses’ approaches to ethics will be. ___3. An...

  • what discuss can you make about medicalization and chronic disease and illness? Adult Lealth Nursing Ethics...

    what discuss can you make about medicalization and chronic disease and illness? Adult Lealth Nursing Ethics mie B. Butts OBJECTIVES After reading this chapter, the reader should be able to do the following: 1. Explore the concept of medicalization as it relates to the societal shift away from physician predominance of the 1970s. 2. Differentiate among the following terms: compliance, noncompliance, adherence, nonadherence, and concordance. 3. Examine cultural views with regard to self-determination, decision making, and American healthcare professionals' values...

  • Case 3: Recruiting CASE THREE: RECRUITING Case Objectives Recruiting is the first stage in which ...

    Case 3: Recruiting CASE THREE: RECRUITING Case Objectives Recruiting is the first stage in which organizational plans for staffing come into contact with the labor market for employees. Before making any new recruiting effort, an organization needs to carefully consider the methods available and balance out the costs of each method with the organization’s needs. The recruiting case provides an opportunity to see how staffing managers develop plans for recruiting efforts. You will develop a recruiting strategy and a recruiting...

  • befor answering the question you have to look at the case. here is the question it...

    befor answering the question you have to look at the case. here is the question it should be 200 words here is the case 3. Should McDonald's offer healthy alternatives to the same extent in all of the countries in which it operates, or just those where it has been criticized in the pa or is it expecting further regulation? What if customers overseas do not want hea options? Global McEthics: should McDonald's ethics be standardized across the globe? This...

  • CASE 2.5 Cosmopolitan Magazine 373 CASE 2.5 cOSMOPOLITAN MAGAZINE Surveys are often sponsored and...

    CASE 2.5 Cosmopolitan Magazine 373 CASE 2.5 cOSMOPOLITAN MAGAZINE Surveys are often sponsored and conducted by various popular press outlets to spur interest among and create a more inreractive relationship with their readers. Nowadays, surveys asking people abour their consumer preferences, shopping behavior, general opi nions, even their sexual habits, are commonplace, but this was not always so. A land mark survey of this kind, often characterized as such due to its ens sample of 106,000, was conducted in 1980,...

ADVERTISEMENT
Free Homework Help App
Download From Google Play
Scan Your Homework
to Get Instant Free Answers
Need Online Homework Help?
Ask a Question
Get Answers For Free
Most questions answered within 3 hours.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT